Shea S, Gemson D H, Mossel P
Department of Medicine, School of Public Health, Columbia University Health Sciences Division, New York, New York.
J Gen Intern Med. 1990 Jul-Aug;5(4):327-34. doi: 10.1007/BF02600401.
To study knowledge of and adherence to National Cholesterol Education Program Adult Treatment Panel (ATP) guidelines among primary care physicians.
Cross-sectional telephone survey.
New York State primary care practitioners; survey conducted November 1988-January 1989.
Physicians in general practice, family practice, internal medicine without subspecialty, and cardiology who reported greater than or equal to 10 hours/week of clinical practice (n = 329; response rate = 63%).
None.
While 84% of physicians had heard of the ATP guidelines, gaps in knowledge and inconsistencies between ATP recommendations and clinical practices were found. Although the ATP guidelines recommend six months of dietary therapy before starting drug treatment, 41% of physicians would initiate drug treatment for a healthy 40-year-old man with total cholesterol of 7.8 mmol/L (300 mg/dl) either at the initial visit or after one month of lipid-lowering diet. Multivariate analysis of a 24-item knowledge scale revealed that less knowledgeable physicians were more likely to be older, lack board certification, and have a specialty other than cardiology (p less than 0.01). Less knowledgeable physicians were also more likely to consider drug company literature and drug company representatives very useful sources of information about cholesterol (p = 0.02).
This study suggests that hard-to-reach physician groups may require special efforts to communicate consensus guidelines of major importance to clinical practice.
研究基层医疗医生对国家胆固醇教育计划成人治疗专家组(ATP)指南的了解程度及遵循情况。
横断面电话调查。
纽约州基层医疗从业者;调查于1988年11月至1989年1月进行。
从事普通科、家庭科、无亚专业的内科以及心脏病学专业,且报告每周临床实践时间不少于10小时的医生(n = 329;应答率 = 63%)。
无。
虽然84%的医生听说过ATP指南,但发现存在知识差距以及ATP建议与临床实践之间的不一致。尽管ATP指南建议在开始药物治疗前进行六个月的饮食治疗,但41%的医生会对一名总胆固醇为7.8 mmol/L(300 mg/dl)的健康40岁男性在初次就诊时或进行一个月降脂饮食后就开始药物治疗。对一个包含24个项目的知识量表进行多变量分析显示,知识较欠缺的医生更可能年龄较大、无专业委员会认证且专业不是心脏病学(p < 0.01)。知识较欠缺的医生也更可能认为制药公司的文献和制药公司代表是关于胆固醇的非常有用的信息来源(p = 0.02)。
本研究表明,对于难以触及的医生群体,可能需要做出特别努力来传达对临床实践至关重要的共识性指南。