School of Health and Related Research, University of Sheffield, Sheffield, S1 4DA, UK.
Pharmacoeconomics. 2013 Aug;31(8):643-52. doi: 10.1007/s40273-013-0069-y.
Decision-analytic models (DAMs) used to evaluate the cost effectiveness of interventions are pivotal sources of evidence used in economic evaluations. Parameter estimates used in the DAMs are often based on the results of a regression analysis, but there is little guidance relating to these. This study had two objectives. The first was to identify the frequency of use of regression models in economic evaluations, the parameters they inform, and the amount of information reported to describe and support the analyses. The second objective was to provide guidance to improve practice in this area, based on the review. The review concentrated on a random sample of economic evaluations submitted to the UK National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) as part of its technology appraisal process. Based on these findings, recommendations for good practice were drafted, together with a checklist for critiquing reporting standards in this area. Based on the results of this review, statistical regression models are in widespread use in DAMs used to support economic evaluations, yet reporting of basic information, such as the sample size used and measures of uncertainty, is limited. Recommendations were formed about how reporting standards could be improved to better meet the needs of decision makers. These recommendations are summarised in a checklist, which may be used by both those conducting regression analyses and those critiquing them, to identify what should be reported when using the results of a regression analysis within a DAM.
用于评估干预措施成本效益的决策分析模型(DAMs)是经济评估中使用的重要证据来源。DAMs 中使用的参数估计通常基于回归分析的结果,但针对这些结果的指导很少。本研究有两个目标。第一个目标是确定回归模型在经济评估中的使用频率、它们提供的参数以及用于描述和支持分析的报告信息量。第二个目标是根据审查结果提供改进这一领域实践的指导。审查重点是随机抽取的、提交给英国国家卫生与临床优化研究所(NICE)作为其技术评估过程一部分的经济评估。基于这些发现,起草了良好实践建议,并为该领域的报告标准制定了一份检查表。基于这项审查的结果,统计回归模型在用于支持经济评估的 DAM 中得到了广泛应用,但对基本信息(如使用的样本量和不确定性度量)的报告却有限。就如何改进报告标准以更好地满足决策者的需求提出了建议。这些建议总结在一份检查表中,无论是进行回归分析的人员还是对其进行评估的人员都可以使用该检查表,以确定在 DAM 中使用回归分析结果时应报告哪些内容。