Child Study Center, Yale University, 230 South Frontage Road, New Haven, CT, 06519-1124, USA,
Ann Dyslexia. 2013 Oct;63(3-4):253-73. doi: 10.1007/s11881-013-0084-x. Epub 2013 Jul 17.
The goal of the study was to investigate the overlap between developmental language disorder (DLD) and developmental dyslexia, identified through spelling difficulties (SD), in Russian-speaking children. In particular, we studied the role of phoneme awareness (PA), rapid automatized naming (RAN), pseudoword repetition (PWR), morphological (MA), and orthographic awareness (OA) in differentiating between children with DLD who have SD from children with DLD who are average spellers by comparing the two groups to each other, to typically developing children as well as children with SD but without spoken language deficits. One hundred forty-nine children, aged 10.40 to 14.00 years, participated in the study. The results indicated that the SD, DLD, and DLD/SD groups did not differ from each other on PA and RAN Letters and underperformed in comparison to the control groups. However, whereas the children with written language deficits (SD and DLD/SD groups) underperformed on RAN Objects and Digits, PWR, OA, and MA, the children with DLD and no SD performed similarly to the children from the control groups on these measures. In contrast, the two groups with spoken language deficits (DLD and DLD/SD) underperformed on RAN Colors in comparison to the control groups and the group of children with SD only. The results support the notion that those children with DLD who have unimpaired PWR and RAN skills are able to overcome their weaknesses in spoken language and PA and acquire basic literacy on a par with their age peers with typical language. We also argue that our findings support a multifactorial model of DLD.
本研究旨在探讨俄语儿童发育性语言障碍(DLD)与发育性阅读障碍(DD)之间的重叠,后者通过拼写困难(SD)来识别。具体而言,我们通过将两组儿童与对照组儿童以及具有 SD 但无口语语言缺陷的儿童进行比较,研究了语音意识(PA)、快速自动命名(RAN)、假词重复(PWR)、形态(MA)和正字法意识(OA)在区分具有 SD 的 DLD 儿童和具有平均拼写能力的 DLD 儿童中的作用。共有 149 名年龄在 10.40 至 14.00 岁的儿童参与了研究。结果表明,SD、DLD 和 DLD/SD 组在 PA 和 RAN 字母上与对照组没有差异,表现不如对照组。然而,与对照组相比,具有书面语言缺陷(SD 和 DLD/SD 组)的儿童在 RAN 物体和数字上表现较差,在 PWR、OA 和 MA 上表现较差,而具有 DLD 且无 SD 的儿童在这些测量上与对照组的儿童表现相似。相比之下,两组口语语言缺陷儿童(DLD 和 DLD/SD)在 RAN 颜色上的表现不如对照组和仅具有 SD 的儿童组。结果支持这样一种观点,即那些具有未受损 PWR 和 RAN 技能的 DLD 儿童能够克服口语语言和 PA 方面的弱点,并获得与具有典型语言的同龄儿童相当的基本读写能力。我们还认为,我们的发现支持 DLD 的多因素模型。