Arbour Counseling Services, Lowell, MA, USA.
Cult Med Psychiatry. 2013 Sep;37(3):427-64. doi: 10.1007/s11013-013-9324-0.
This article profiles bereavement among traumatized Cambodian refugees and explores the validity of a model of how grief and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) interact in this group to form a unique bereavement ontology, a model in which dreams of the dead play a crucial role. Several studies were conducted at a psychiatric clinic treating Cambodian refugees who survived the Pol Pot genocide. Key findings included that Pol Pot deaths were made even more deeply disturbing owing to cultural ideas about "bad death" and the consequences of not performing mortuary rites; that pained recall of the dead in the last month was common (76 % of patients) and usually caused great emotional and somatic distress; that severity of pained recall of the dead was strongly associated with PTSD severity (r = .62); that pained recall was very often triggered by dreaming about the dead, usually of someone who died in the Pol Pot period; and that Cambodians have a complex system of interpretation of dreams of the deceased that frequently causes those dreams to give rise to great distress. Cases are provided that further illustrate the centrality of dreams of the dead in the Cambodian experiencing of grief and PTSD. The article shows that not assessing dreams and concerns about the spiritual status of the deceased in the evaluation of bereavement results in "category truncation," i.e., a lack of content validity, a form of category fallacy.
这篇文章介绍了创伤后柬埔寨难民的丧亲之痛,并探讨了悲伤和创伤后应激障碍 (PTSD) 在这一群体中相互作用形成独特丧亲本体论的有效性,在这个模型中,死者的梦起着至关重要的作用。几项研究在一家治疗经历过波尔布特种族灭绝的柬埔寨难民的精神病诊所进行。主要发现包括,由于关于“恶死”和不进行葬礼仪式的后果的文化观念,波尔布特的死亡更加令人深感不安;在最后一个月痛苦地回忆死者是很常见的(76%的患者),通常会引起巨大的情绪和躯体痛苦;对死者的痛苦回忆的严重程度与 PTSD 的严重程度强烈相关(r =.62);对死者的痛苦回忆常常是由梦见死者引起的,通常是在波尔布特时期去世的人;柬埔寨人有一个复杂的死者梦的解释系统,这常常导致这些梦引起巨大的痛苦。提供了一些案例,进一步说明了死者的梦在柬埔寨人经历悲伤和 PTSD 中的核心地位。这篇文章表明,在评估丧亲之痛时,如果不评估梦和对死者精神状态的担忧,会导致“类别截断”,即缺乏内容有效性,这是一种范畴谬误。