Sgouramani Helena, Vatakis Argiro
Postgraduate Program Basic and Applied Cognitive Science, Department of Philosophy and History of Science, University of Athens, Athens, Greece.
Postgraduate Program Basic and Applied Cognitive Science, Department of Philosophy and History of Science, University of Athens, Athens, Greece; Cognitive Systems Research Institute (CSRI), Athens, Greece.
Acta Psychol (Amst). 2014 Mar;147:17-24. doi: 10.1016/j.actpsy.2013.06.009. Epub 2013 Aug 1.
Speed has been proposed as a modulating factor on duration estimation. However, the different measurement methodologies and experimental designs used have led to inconsistent results across studies, and, thus, the issue of how speed modulates time estimation remains unresolved. Additionally, no studies have looked into the role of expertise on spatiotemporal tasks (tasks requiring high temporal and spatial acuity; e.g., dancing) and susceptibility to modulations of speed in timing judgments. In the present study, therefore, using naturalistic, dynamic dance stimuli, we aimed at defining the role of speed and the interaction of speed and experience on time estimation. We presented videos of a dancer performing identical ballet steps in fast and slow versions, while controlling for the number of changes present. Professional dancers and non-dancers performed duration judgments through a production and a reproduction task. Analysis revealed a significantly larger underestimation of fast videos as compared to slow ones during reproduction. The exact opposite result was true for the production task. Dancers were significantly less variable in their time estimations as compared to non-dancers. Speed and experience, therefore, affect the participants' estimates of time. Results are discussed in association to the theoretical framework of current models by focusing on the role of attention.
速度已被提出作为持续时间估计的一个调节因素。然而,所使用的不同测量方法和实验设计导致了各研究结果不一致,因此,速度如何调节时间估计的问题仍未得到解决。此外,尚无研究探讨专业技能在时空任务(需要高时间和空间敏锐度的任务,如舞蹈)中的作用以及在时间判断中对速度调节的敏感性。因此,在本研究中,我们使用自然主义的动态舞蹈刺激,旨在确定速度的作用以及速度与经验在时间估计中的相互作用。我们展示了一名舞者以快、慢两种版本表演相同芭蕾舞步的视频,同时控制其中出现的变化数量。专业舞者和非舞者通过生成任务和复制任务进行持续时间判断。分析显示,在复制过程中,与慢视频相比,快视频的低估程度明显更大。在生成任务中,结果正好相反。与非舞者相比,舞者在时间估计中的变异性显著更小。因此,速度和经验会影响参与者的时间估计。通过关注注意力的作用,结合当前模型的理论框架对结果进行了讨论。