Endress Ansgar D, Potter Mary C
Department of Brain and Cognitive Sciences, Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
J Exp Psychol Gen. 2014 Apr;143(2):548-65. doi: 10.1037/a0033934. Epub 2013 Aug 12.
Visual working memory (WM) capacity is thought to be limited to 3 or 4 items. However, many cognitive activities seem to require larger temporary memory stores. Here, we provide evidence for a temporary memory store with much larger capacity than past WM capacity estimates. Further, based on previous WM research, we show that a single factor--proactive interference--is sufficient to bring capacity estimates down to the range of previous WM capacity estimates. Participants saw a rapid serial visual presentation of 5-21 pictures of familiar objects or words presented at rates of 4/s or 8/s, respectively, and thus too fast for strategies such as rehearsal. Recognition memory was tested with a single probe item. When new items were used on all trials, no fixed memory capacities were observed, with estimates of up to 9.1 retained pictures for 21-item lists, and up to 30.0 retained pictures for 100-item lists, and no clear upper bound to how many items could be retained. Further, memory items were not stored in a temporally stable form of memory but decayed almost completely after a few minutes. In contrast, when, as in most WM experiments, a small set of items was reused across all trials, thus creating proactive interference among items, capacity remained in the range reported in previous WM experiments. These results show that humans have a large-capacity temporary memory store in the absence of proactive interference, and raise the question of whether temporary memory in everyday cognitive processing is severely limited, as in WM experiments, or has the much larger capacity found in the present experiments.
视觉工作记忆(WM)容量被认为限制在3到4个项目。然而,许多认知活动似乎需要更大的临时记忆存储。在此,我们提供证据表明存在一种临时记忆存储,其容量比过去对WM容量的估计要大得多。此外,基于先前的WM研究,我们表明单一因素——前摄干扰——足以使容量估计降至先前WM容量估计的范围内。参与者分别以4幅/秒或8幅/秒的速度快速连续视觉呈现5至21张熟悉物体或单词的图片,速度太快以至于无法采用复述等策略。用单个探测项目测试识别记忆。当所有试验都使用新项目时,未观察到固定的记忆容量,对于21个项目的列表,最多可保留9.1张图片,对于100个项目的列表,最多可保留30.0张图片,并且对于可保留的项目数量没有明确的上限。此外,记忆项目并非以时间上稳定的记忆形式存储,而是在几分钟后几乎完全衰退。相比之下,正如大多数WM实验那样,当在所有试验中重复使用一小套项目,从而在项目之间产生前摄干扰时,容量仍处于先前WM实验所报告的范围内。这些结果表明,在没有前摄干扰的情况下,人类具有大容量的临时记忆存储,并提出了一个问题,即在日常认知处理中的临时记忆是否像WM实验那样受到严重限制,还是具有本实验中发现的大得多的容量。