School of Psychology, University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK.
Aggress Behav. 2014 Mar-Apr;40(2):165-77. doi: 10.1002/ab.21506. Epub 2013 Sep 9.
In response to concerns regarding the rise in female juvenile violent crime and the dearth of gender-specific research, this study aimed to identify predictors of violent offending in female offenders. Data were extracted from risk assessments of 586 male and female juvenile offenders (aged 11-17 years) conducted between 2005 and 2009 by the Youth Offending Service in Gloucestershire, an English county. Information regarding the young people's living arrangements, family and personal relationships, education, emotional/mental health, thinking and behavior, and attitudes to offending was recorded. Comparisons were made between the violent male offenders (N = 185), the violent female offenders (N = 113), the non-violent male offenders (N = 150), and the non-violent female offenders (N = 138) for these variables. These were followed by a multinomial logistic regression analysis. The findings indicated that engaging in self-harm was the best predictor of being a female violent offender, with the predictors of giving into pressure from others and attempted suicide nearing significance. Furthermore, non-violent females were significantly less likely to lose control of their temper and more likely to give in to pressure from others than their violent counterparts. Non-violent males were significantly less likely to lose control of their temper and more likely to self-harm and give in to pressure from others than violent males. Although many similarities existed between sexes for predictors of violent offending, the findings of this study indicate that more attention needs to be paid to the mental health of female offenders.
针对女性青少年暴力犯罪增加以及缺乏针对性别研究的问题,本研究旨在确定女性罪犯暴力犯罪的预测因素。数据来自格洛斯特郡青少年犯罪服务处(Youth Offending Service)于 2005 年至 2009 年期间对 586 名男性和女性青少年罪犯(年龄在 11-17 岁之间)进行的风险评估,这些青少年罪犯的生活安排、家庭和人际关系、教育、情感/心理健康、思维和行为以及犯罪态度等信息都有记录。对暴力男性罪犯(N=185)、暴力女性罪犯(N=113)、非暴力男性罪犯(N=150)和非暴力女性罪犯(N=138)的这些变量进行了比较。随后进行了多项逻辑回归分析。研究结果表明,自残是成为女性暴力罪犯的最佳预测因素,屈服于他人压力和试图自杀的预测因素也接近显著。此外,非暴力女性比暴力女性更不容易发脾气,更有可能屈服于他人的压力。非暴力男性比暴力男性更不容易发脾气,更有可能自残和屈服于他人的压力。尽管性别之间存在许多相似的暴力犯罪预测因素,但本研究的结果表明,需要更加关注女性罪犯的心理健康。