Gower Menna, Morgan Frank, Saunders Julie
School of Population and Global Health, University of Western Australia, Perth, WA, Australia.
Psychiatr Psychol Law. 2023 Jul 4;31(4):587-611. doi: 10.1080/13218719.2023.2206855. eCollection 2024.
Risk assessment tools used to assess justice-involved women have been predominantly developed using male offenders, with validations for females having mixed results. Female-specific risk assessment tools are not well established, and validations are limited. In terms of treatment, either programmes in various jurisdictions have been developed specifically for females, or addendums are available to assist in the facilitation of programmes initially developed for male offenders. The efficacy of these has been varied with gender-responsive programmes proving to be more successful in the reduction of reoffending if justice-involved women follow a gender-specific pathway to offending than if they follow a non-gender-specific pathway. This paper discusses gender differences in offending and provides an overview of assessment and treatment of justice-involved women in Australia, the UK, New Zealand and Canada. The assessment and treatment practices for justice-involved women are viewed through an evidence-based lens, and opportunities for future development are identified.
用于评估涉案女性的风险评估工具主要是基于男性罪犯开发的,对女性的验证结果参差不齐。专门针对女性的风险评估工具尚未完善,验证也很有限。在治疗方面,不同司法管辖区要么专门为女性制定了项目,要么提供附录以协助实施最初为男性罪犯制定的项目。这些项目的效果各不相同,事实证明,如果涉案女性遵循特定性别的犯罪途径,那么针对性别做出反应的项目在减少再次犯罪方面比遵循非特定性别的途径更为成功。本文讨论了犯罪中的性别差异,并概述了澳大利亚、英国、新西兰和加拿大对涉案女性的评估和治疗情况。我们从循证的角度审视了涉案女性的评估和治疗实践,并确定了未来发展的机会。