School of Pharmacy, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
Am J Pharm Educ. 2013 Sep 12;77(7):151. doi: 10.5688/ajpe777151.
To assess the effectiveness of virtual patient cases to promote self-directed learning (SDL) in a required advanced therapeutics course.
Virtual patient software based on a branched-narrative decision-making model was used to create complex patient case simulations to replace lecture-based instruction. Within each simulation, students used SDL principles to learn course objectives, apply their knowledge through clinical recommendations, and assess their progress through patient outcomes and faculty feedback linked to their individual decisions. Group discussions followed each virtual patient case to provide further interpretation, clarification, and clinical perspective.
Students found the simulated patient cases to be organized (90%), enjoyable (82%), intellectually challenging (97%), and valuable to their understanding of course content (91%). Students further indicated that completion of the virtual patient cases prior to class permitted better use of class time (78%) and promoted SDL (84%). When assessment questions regarding material on postoperative nausea and vomiting were compared, no difference in scores were found between the students who attended the lecture on the material in 2011 (control group) and those who completed the virtual patient case on the material in 2012 (intervention group).
Completion of virtual patient cases, designed to replace lectures and promote SDL, was overwhelmingly supported by students and proved to be as effective as traditional teaching methods.
评估虚拟患者病例在一门必修高级治疗课程中促进自主学习(SDL)的效果。
基于分支叙事决策模型的虚拟患者软件被用来创建复杂的患者病例模拟,以替代基于讲座的教学。在每个模拟中,学生运用 SDL 原则学习课程目标,通过临床建议应用他们的知识,并通过与他们个人决策相关联的患者结果和教师反馈评估他们的进展。每次虚拟患者病例后都会进行小组讨论,以提供进一步的解释、澄清和临床视角。
学生认为模拟患者病例组织有序(90%)、有趣(82%)、具有挑战性(97%),并且对他们理解课程内容有价值(91%)。学生还表示,在上课前完成虚拟患者病例可以更好地利用课堂时间(78%),并促进 SDL(84%)。当比较关于术后恶心和呕吐相关材料的评估问题时,在 2011 年参加该材料讲座的学生(对照组)和在 2012 年完成该材料虚拟患者病例的学生(干预组)之间的分数没有差异。
完成虚拟患者病例,旨在替代讲座和促进 SDL,受到学生的大力支持,并且被证明与传统教学方法一样有效。