Hazel Susan J, Heberle Nicole, McEwen Margaret-Mary, Adams Karen
J Vet Med Educ. 2013 Winter;40(4):333-41. doi: 10.3138/jvme.0213-034R1.
Team-based learning (TBL) was implemented into a first-year course (Principles in Animal Behaviour, Welfare and Ethics) for BSc Veterinary Bioscience (VB) and Animal Science (AS) students. TBL is now used widely in teaching medical students, but has had more limited uptake in veterinary education. This study reports its use over 2 years with cohorts of 126 and 138 students in 2011 and 2012, respectively. Average individual marks for multiple-choice question (MCQ) tests in the Readiness Assurance component of TBL were higher for the teams than for individuals for each session, explicitly demonstrating the advantages of teamwork. Students reported that they felt actively involved and that TBL helped them both with their learning and in developing other important skills, such as teamwork and communication. Qualitative analysis of written feedback from the students revealed positive themes of discussion, application, revelation, socializing, engagement, clarification, and retention/revision. In 2011 negative comments included the need to shorten the TBL sessions, but in 2012 tightening of the timelines meant that this was no longer a major concern. Requests to provide better introductory and background materials and ambiguity in questions in the TBL activities were what students least liked about the TBL. However, most comments were positive rather than negative in nature, and many students preferred the TBL to lectures. With requirements for curricula to teach professional skills, such as communication and teamwork, and the positive results from TBL's implementation, it is hoped that this study will encourage others to trial the use of TBL in veterinary education.
基于团队的学习(TBL)被应用于兽医学理学学士(VB)和动物科学(AS)专业一年级学生的课程(动物行为、福利与伦理原理)中。TBL目前在医学生教学中被广泛使用,但在兽医教育中的应用相对有限。本研究报告了其在2011年和2012年分别对126名和138名学生群体进行的为期两年的使用情况。在TBL的准备保证环节中,团队在多项选择题(MCQ)测试中的平均个人成绩在每次课程中都高于个人成绩,这明确显示了团队合作的优势。学生们表示他们积极参与其中,并且TBL在学习以及培养团队合作和沟通等其他重要技能方面对他们有帮助。对学生书面反馈的定性分析揭示了讨论、应用、启示、社交、参与、澄清以及记忆/复习等积极主题。2011年的负面评论包括需要缩短TBL课程,但在2012年,时间安排的紧凑意味着这不再是一个主要问题。学生最不喜欢TBL的地方是要求提供更好的介绍性和背景材料以及TBL活动中问题的模糊性。然而,大多数评论本质上是积极的而非消极的,并且许多学生更喜欢TBL而不是讲座。鉴于课程要求教授沟通和团队合作等专业技能,以及TBL实施所取得的积极成果,希望本研究能鼓励其他人在兽医教育中尝试使用TBL。