University of Castilla-La Mancha, Faculty of Education , Spain.
J Sports Sci Med. 2010 Jun 1;9(2):190-8. eCollection 2010.
The purpose of this study was to identify the existence of Relative Age Effect (RAE) at youth level in both elite and amateur Spanish soccer clubs, and also to carry out an analysis providing with information on how this effect has evolved in recent years. We have obtained information on the youth teams of the 20 clubs belonging to the Spanish Professional Football League (LFP) in two separate seasons (2005-2006 and 2008-2009) as well as data on five youth academies belonging to amateur clubs. The collected data revealed an over- representation of players born in the first months of the selection year in all groups of analysis (Elite 2005-2006, Elite 2008-2009 and Amateurs), although only the Elite groups showed significant variations in birth-date distribution in relation to the Spanish population. The results showed a reduction in RAE from the 2005-2006 season to the 2008-2009 season. The following variables - playing position, the number of years each player has spent in their specific age group and the category of the team at each club were shown not to have influence on the extent of RAE. Key pointsThere was RAE in all groups analyzed, although only the Elite groups showed significant variations in birth-date distribution in relation to the general population.RAE is more evident in the Elite groups than in the Amateur probably because of the detection process, which is more thorough in the Elite groups.Playing position, number of years in their specific age group and category of the team did not have any influence on the extent of RAE.Any attempts to prevent RAE should be based on a stable sport policy and the implication of all the stakeholders in the system. All of them should think in the development of a player as a long-term project.
本研究旨在确定西班牙精英和业余足球俱乐部青年队中是否存在相对年龄效应(RAE),并进行分析,提供有关该效应近年来如何演变的信息。我们获取了西班牙职业足球联赛(LFP)的 20 家俱乐部的青年队在两个不同赛季(2005-2006 年和 2008-2009 年)的信息,以及五个业余俱乐部青年学院的数据。收集的数据显示,在所有分析组(精英 2005-2006 年、精英 2008-2009 年和业余)中,选拔年份首几个月出生的球员比例过高,尽管只有精英组在出生日期分布方面与西班牙人口存在显著差异。结果显示,从 2005-2006 赛季到 2008-2009 赛季,RAE 有所减少。以下变量——球员的场上位置、在特定年龄组中度过的年数以及每个俱乐部的球队级别,均未对 RAE 的程度产生影响。要点所有分析组都存在 RAE,尽管只有精英组在出生日期分布方面与普通人群存在显著差异。RAE 在精英组中比在业余组中更为明显,可能是因为在精英组中检测过程更为彻底。球员的场上位置、在特定年龄组中度过的年数和球队级别对 RAE 的程度没有任何影响。任何防止 RAE 的尝试都应该基于稳定的体育政策和系统中所有利益相关者的参与。他们都应该将球员的发展视为一个长期项目。