Ho Chi-Lin, Fu Yun-Ching, Lin Ming-Chih, Chan Sheng-Ching, Hwang Betau, Jan Sheng-Ling
Department of Pediatrics, Taichung Veterans General Hospital, 160, Sec. 3, Chung-Kang Road, Taichung, 40705, Taiwan.
Pediatr Cardiol. 2014 Apr;35(4):726-31. doi: 10.1007/s00246-013-0844-8. Epub 2013 Nov 21.
Heart rate (HR) measurement is essential for children with abnormal heart beats. The purpose of this study was to determine whether HR measurement by smartphone applications (apps) could be a feasible alternative to an electrocardiography (ECG) monitor. A total of 40 children, median age of 4.3 years, were studied. Using four free smartphone apps, pulse rates were measured at the finger (or toe) and earlobe, and compared with baseline HRs measured by ECG monitors. Significant correlations between measured pulse rates and baseline HRs were found. Both correlation and accuracy rate were higher in the earlobe group than the finger/toe group. When HR was <120 beats per min (bpm), the accuracy rates were not different between the two different measuring sites for each app (median of 65 vs 76%). The accuracy rates in the finger/toe group were significantly lower than those in the earlobe group for all apps when HR was ≥ 120 bpm (27 vs 65%). There were differences among apps in their abilities to measure pulse rates. Taking children's pulse rate from the earlobe would be more accurate, especially for tachycardia. However, we do not recommend that smartphone apps should not be used for routine medical use or used as the sole form of HR measurement because the results of their accuracy are not good enough.
心率(HR)测量对于心跳异常的儿童至关重要。本研究的目的是确定通过智能手机应用程序(应用)测量心率是否可以作为心电图(ECG)监测仪的一种可行替代方法。共研究了40名儿童,中位年龄为4.3岁。使用四款免费智能手机应用,在手指(或脚趾)和耳垂处测量脉搏率,并与通过ECG监测仪测量的基线心率进行比较。发现测量的脉搏率与基线心率之间存在显著相关性。耳垂组的相关性和准确率均高于手指/脚趾组。当心率<120次/分钟(bpm)时,每个应用在两个不同测量部位的准确率没有差异(中位数分别为65%和76%)。当心率≥120 bpm时,所有应用在手指/脚趾组的准确率均显著低于耳垂组(27%对65%)。不同应用在测量脉搏率的能力方面存在差异。从耳垂测量儿童脉搏率会更准确,尤其是对于心动过速。然而,我们不建议将智能手机应用用于常规医疗用途或作为心率测量的唯一形式,因为其准确性结果不够理想。