Gastrointestinal Unit, Department of Gastroenterology, University of Pisa, Via Paradisa No. 2, 56100, Pisa, Italy,
Tech Coloproctol. 2014 Jun;18(6):543-9. doi: 10.1007/s10151-013-1093-9. Epub 2013 Nov 22.
Chronic constipation is often diagnosed and treated by general practitioners (GPs). The aim of the study was to evaluate the management of constipation by a cohort of Italian GPs.
Over the course of 1 month, 41 GPs recorded tests and therapies suggested to patients complaining of chronic constipation. They were classified according to the Rome III criteria as constipated irritable bowel syndrome (C-IBS), functional constipation (FC), or "self-perceived constipation" (SPC) (not consistent with the Rome criteria).
The most frequently prescribed tests for the 229 patients (147 FC, 50 C-IBS, 32 SPC) were routine blood tests (59.3 %), abdominal ultrasounds (37.2 %), thyroid function (36.7 %), fecal occult blood tests (36.7 %), and tumor markers (35 %). Patient sex and age, GP age, and whether the diagnosis was new influenced the GP's request, but FC, C-IBS, or SPC status did not. Dietary suggestions (81.9 %), fiber supplements (59.7 %), reassurance (50.9 %), and laxatives (30.5 %) were the most frequently prescribed treatments. Antispasmodics were more frequently suggested for C-IBS patients; dietary suggestions, fiber, and enemas were more frequently prescribed in SPC patients. Patient and GP age and whether the diagnosis was new influenced the GP's choice of treatment.
The Rome III criteria do not influence diagnostic strategies and only slightly influence therapeutic strategies of GPs. Other factors (age, gender, new or old diagnosis) have more influence on GPs choice of investigations and treatment.
慢性便秘通常由全科医生(GP)进行诊断和治疗。本研究旨在评估意大利全科医生对便秘的管理情况。
在 1 个月的时间内,41 名全科医生记录了抱怨慢性便秘的患者接受的检查和治疗建议。他们根据罗马 III 标准分为便秘型肠易激综合征(C-IBS)、功能性便秘(FC)或“自我感知便秘”(SPC)(不符合罗马标准)。
对 229 名患者(147 例 FC、50 例 C-IBS、32 例 SPC)进行的最常见检查是常规血液检查(59.3%)、腹部超声(37.2%)、甲状腺功能检查(36.7%)、粪便潜血检查(36.7%)和肿瘤标志物检查(35%)。患者性别和年龄、GP 年龄以及诊断是否为新诊断影响了 GP 的要求,但 FC、C-IBS 或 SPC 状态并未影响。饮食建议(81.9%)、纤维补充剂(59.7%)、安慰(50.9%)和泻药(30.5%)是最常开的治疗方法。痉挛性药物更常被建议用于 C-IBS 患者;饮食建议、纤维和灌肠剂在 SPC 患者中更常被开处。患者和 GP 年龄以及诊断是否为新诊断影响了 GP 治疗的选择。
罗马 III 标准并不影响 GP 的诊断策略,仅略微影响治疗策略。其他因素(年龄、性别、新诊断或旧诊断)对 GP 检查和治疗的选择有更大的影响。