Brown Gillian, Marshall Max, Bower Peter, Woodham Adrine, Waheed Waquas
Division of Psychiatry, School of Medicine, University of Manchester, Manchester, UK.
Int J Methods Psychiatr Res. 2014 Mar;23(1):36-48. doi: 10.1002/mpr.1434. Epub 2014 Jan 28.
Disparities in the prevalence of mental illness are widely reported for people from ethnic minorities. Unlike the United States, there is no legislation for clinical research in the UK to mandate the inclusion of ethnic minorities and they are underrepresented in European trials compared with those conducted in the United States. This restricts generalization of research findings. This systematic review of the barriers to the recruitment of ethnic minority participants into psychiatric research is based on a comprehensive literature search. Nine included papers explore such barriers based on the authors' and participants' experiences of research. These barriers are mainly categorized as: participant related, practical issues, family/community related, health service related and research process issues. This review provides a compilation of important barriers to recruitment which can facilitate future research. The barriers that were identified are not all unique to participants from ethnic minorities, although the way in which they manifest themselves is often distinct in minority groups. It is important that these barriers are considered when designing research design so that solutions to overcome such obstacles can be incorporated in research protocols from the start and appropriate resources allocated.
少数族裔人群中精神疾病患病率的差异已被广泛报道。与美国不同,英国没有临床研究立法强制纳入少数族裔,与美国开展的试验相比,他们在欧洲试验中的代表性不足。这限制了研究结果的推广。这项关于少数族裔参与者纳入精神病学研究的障碍的系统评价基于全面的文献检索。九篇纳入论文根据作者和参与者的研究经历探讨了此类障碍。这些障碍主要分为:与参与者相关的、实际问题、与家庭/社区相关的、与卫生服务相关的以及研究过程问题。本综述汇编了招募的重要障碍,可为未来研究提供便利。所确定的障碍并非少数族裔参与者所独有,尽管它们在少数群体中的表现方式往往有所不同。在设计研究时考虑这些障碍很重要,以便从一开始就将克服此类障碍的解决方案纳入研究方案并分配适当的资源。