FitzGerald Deirdre, Grainger Rachel J, Reid Alex
Medmark Occupational Healthcare, 28 Penrose Wharf, Cork, Ireland.
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2014 Feb 24;2014(2):CD009943. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD009943.pub2.
Scabies, caused by Sarcoptes scabiei variety hominis or the human itch mite, is a common parasitic infection. While anyone can become infected, it causes significant morbidity in immunocompromised hosts and it spreads easily between human hosts where there is overcrowding or poor sanitation. The most common symptom reported is itch which is worse at night. As the symptoms are attributed to an allergic reaction to the mite, symptoms usually develop between four to six weeks after primary infection. Therefore, people may be infected for some time prior to developing symptoms. During this time, while asymptomatic, they may spread infection to others they are in close contact with. Consequently, it is usually recommended that when an index case is being treated, others who have been in close contact with the index case should also be provided with treatment.
To assess the effects of prophylactic interventions for contacts of people with scabies to prevent infestation in the contacts.
We searched electronic databases (Cochrane Occupational Safety and Health Review Group Specialised Register, CENTRAL (The Cochrane Library), MEDLINE (Ovid), Pubmed, EMBASE, LILACS, CINAHL, OpenGrey and WHO ICTRP) up to November 2013.
Randomised controlled trials (RCTs) or cluster RCTs which compared prophylactic interventions which were given to contacts of index cases with scabies infestation. Interventions could be compared to each other, or to placebo or to no treatment. Both drug treatments and non-drug treatments were acceptable.
Two authors intended to extract dichotomous data (developed infection or did not develop infection) for the effects of interventions and report this as risk ratios with 95% confidence intervals. We intended to report any adverse outcomes similarly.
We did not include any trials in this review. Out of 29 potentially-relevant studies, we excluded 16 RCTs as the data for the contacts were either not reported or were reported only in combination with the outcomes for the index cases. We excluded a further 11 studies as they were not RCTs. We also excluded one study as not all subjects were examined at baseline and follow-up, and another as it was a case study.
AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS: The effects of providing prophylactic treatments for contacts of people with scabies to prevent infestation are unknown. We need well-designed RCTs of the use of prophylactic measures to prevent the transmission of scabies conducted with people who had the opportunity for prolonged skin contact with an index case, such as family members, healthcare workers or residential care personnel, within the previous six weeks.
疥疮由人型疥螨引起,是一种常见的寄生虫感染。任何人都可能被感染,但在免疫功能低下的宿主中会导致严重发病,且在人群拥挤或卫生条件差的环境中容易在人与人之间传播。最常见的症状是瘙痒,夜间更严重。由于这些症状归因于对螨虫的过敏反应,症状通常在初次感染后四至六周出现。因此,人们在出现症状之前可能已感染一段时间。在此期间,虽然无症状,但他们可能会将感染传播给与之密切接触的其他人。因此,通常建议在治疗首例病例时,也应为与首例病例密切接触的其他人提供治疗。
评估对疥疮患者的接触者进行预防性干预以防止其感染的效果。
我们检索了截至2013年11月的电子数据库(Cochrane职业安全与健康综述小组专业注册库、CENTRAL(Cochrane图书馆)、MEDLINE(Ovid)、Pubmed、EMBASE、LILACS、CINAHL、OpenGrey和WHO ICTRP)。
随机对照试验(RCT)或整群RCT,比较对疥疮感染首例病例的接触者给予预防性干预的效果。干预措施可相互比较,或与安慰剂或不治疗进行比较。药物治疗和非药物治疗均可接受。
两位作者打算提取干预效果的二分数据(发生感染或未发生感染),并将其报告为具有95%置信区间的风险比。我们打算以类似方式报告任何不良结局。
本综述未纳入任何试验。在29项可能相关的研究中,我们排除了16项RCT,因为接触者的数据要么未报告,要么仅与首例病例的结局合并报告。我们又排除了11项研究,因为它们不是RCT。我们还排除了一项研究,因为并非所有受试者在基线和随访时都接受了检查,以及另一项研究,因为它是一项病例研究。
对疥疮患者的接触者提供预防性治疗以防止感染的效果尚不清楚。我们需要针对曾在过去六周内有机会与首例病例长时间皮肤接触的人群(如家庭成员、医护人员或住院护理人员)进行精心设计的RCT,以研究使用预防措施预防疥疮传播的效果。