Cardamone Salvatore, Hughes Timothy J, Popelier Paul L A
Manchester Institute of Biotechnology (MIB), 131 Princess Street, Manchester, M1 7DN, UK.
Phys Chem Chem Phys. 2014 Jun 14;16(22):10367-87. doi: 10.1039/c3cp54829e.
Atomistic simulation of chemical systems is currently limited by the elementary description of electrostatics that atomic point-charges offer. Unfortunately, a model of one point-charge for each atom fails to capture the anisotropic nature of electronic features such as lone pairs or π-systems. Higher order electrostatic terms, such as those offered by a multipole moment expansion, naturally recover these important electronic features. The question remains as to why such a description has not yet been widely adopted by popular molecular mechanics force fields. There are two widely-held misconceptions about the more rigorous formalism of multipolar electrostatics: (1) Accuracy: the implementation of multipole moments, compared to point-charges, offers little to no advantage in terms of an accurate representation of a system's energetics, structure and dynamics. (2) Efficiency: atomistic simulation using multipole moments is computationally prohibitive compared to simulation using point-charges. Whilst the second of these may have found some basis when computational power was a limiting factor, the first has no theoretical grounding. In the current work, we disprove the two statements above and systematically demonstrate that multipole moments are not discredited by either. We hope that this perspective will help in catalysing the transition to more realistic electrostatic modelling, to be adopted by popular molecular simulation software.
目前,化学系统的原子模拟受到原子点电荷所提供的静电学基本描述的限制。不幸的是,每个原子一个点电荷的模型无法捕捉诸如孤对电子或π体系等电子特征的各向异性本质。更高阶的静电项,例如由多极矩展开提供的那些项,自然地恢复了这些重要的电子特征。问题仍然存在,即为什么这样的描述尚未被流行的分子力学力场广泛采用。关于多极静电学更严格形式存在两种普遍的误解:(1)准确性:与点电荷相比,多极矩的实现对于准确表示系统的能量、结构和动力学几乎没有优势。(2)效率:与使用点电荷的模拟相比,使用多极矩的原子模拟在计算上是令人望而却步的。虽然当计算能力是一个限制因素时,第二个误解可能有一定依据,但第一个误解没有理论基础。在当前的工作中,我们反驳了上述两个说法,并系统地证明多极矩在这两方面都没有问题。我们希望这一观点将有助于推动向更现实的静电建模的转变,以供流行的分子模拟软件采用。