Vogel Rachel Isaksson, Hertsgaard Louise A, Dermody Sarah S, Luo Xianghua, Moua Lor, Allen Sharon, al'Absi Mustafa, Hatsukami Dorothy K
University of Minnesota, Masonic Comprehensive Cancer Center, Minneapolis, MN, United States.
University of Minnesota, Tobacco Research Programs, Minneapolis, MN, United States.
Addict Behav. 2014 Jul;39(7):1197-204. doi: 10.1016/j.addbeh.2014.03.021. Epub 2014 Mar 30.
When switching from usual brand cigarettes, very low nicotine content (VLNC) cigarettes lead to a reduction in the number of cigarettes smoked, toxicant exposure, withdrawal symptoms and dependence. One area that has been relatively unexplored is what factors might moderate the effects of VLNC cigarettes. This exploratory analysis focuses on sex differences in responses to VLNC cigarettes and nicotine replacement therapy.
An exploratory secondary analysis of a randomized trial of 235 participants (58% female, mean age 47 years) comparing a) 0.05-0.09 mg nicotine yield cigarettes; b) 21 mg nicotine patch and 3) 0.05-0.09 nicotine yield cigarettes with 21 mg nicotine patch was conducted. We focused on sex differences in product use, and impact of products on withdrawal response from usual brand cigarettes and abstinence by randomized group.
The combination of VLNC cigarettes and nicotine patch was more effective in reducing use of VLNC cigarettes and withdrawal symptoms among males than females, whereas females were equally responsive to VLNC cigarettes with and without the nicotine patch. Females were more likely to quit smoking than males when assigned to either of the conditions that incorporated the VLNC cigarettes; however, males were more likely to quit smoking in the nicotine patch alone condition than females.
Sex of the smoker may be an important determinant for effects of VLNC cigarettes and nicotine patch. Future large randomized trials to confirm these results are needed.
从普通品牌香烟改用极低尼古丁含量(VLNC)香烟时,可减少吸烟量、接触毒物量、戒断症状及成瘾性。一个相对未被充分探索的领域是哪些因素可能会调节VLNC香烟的效果。本探索性分析聚焦于对VLNC香烟和尼古丁替代疗法反应的性别差异。
对一项随机试验进行探索性二次分析,该试验有235名参与者(58%为女性,平均年龄47岁),比较了以下三种情况:a)尼古丁产率为0.05 - 0.09毫克的香烟;b)21毫克尼古丁贴片;c)尼古丁产率为0.05 - 0.09毫克的香烟与21毫克尼古丁贴片联用。我们关注产品使用方面的性别差异,以及产品对从普通品牌香烟戒断反应和按随机分组的戒烟情况的影响。
VLNC香烟与尼古丁贴片联用在减少男性使用VLNC香烟及戒断症状方面比女性更有效,而女性对有无尼古丁贴片的VLNC香烟反应相同。当被分配到包含VLNC香烟的任何一种情况时,女性比男性更有可能戒烟;然而,仅使用尼古丁贴片时,男性比女性更有可能戒烟。
吸烟者的性别可能是VLNC香烟和尼古丁贴片效果的重要决定因素。未来需要进行大规模随机试验来证实这些结果。