Slinin Yelena, Guo Haifeng, Li Suying, Liu Jiannong, Ensrud Kristine, Gilbertson David T, Collins Allan J, Ishani Areef
Veterans Administration Health Care System, Minneapolis, Minn., USA.
Am J Nephrol. 2014;39(5):367-75. doi: 10.1159/000362286. Epub 2014 Apr 23.
BACKGROUND/AIMS: Physician characteristics are associated with differential performance on quality measures and patient outcomes in several medical fields. We aimed to determine whether characteristics of physicians who provide care to dialysis patients were associated with patient outcomes.
This cohort study used United States Renal Data System data for patients who initiated in-center hemodialysis between October 1, 2003, and September 30, 2006 (n = 91,276). Patient characteristics were defined and physicians identified from Part B Medicare claims for outpatient dialysis services submitted during months 4-6 of hemodialysis. Physician characteristics were obtained from the American Medical Association Physician Master File. Associations of physician characteristics with 1-year patient mortality and first hospitalization were determined using Cox proportional hazards analysis; associations with quality of care (defined by influenza vaccination and waitlisting for kidney transplant) were determined using logistic regression.
Physician characteristics were not associated with patient mortality. After adjustment for patient and other provider characteristics, patients whose physicians had practiced longer or were in administrative, research, or teaching practices were more likely to be hospitalized; patients whose providers practiced in smaller metropolitan statistical areas (MSAs) were less likely. More years since training was associated with greater chance of waitlisting, and practicing in smaller MSAs with less chance. Graduation from a foreign medical school, practicing in smaller MSAs, and travelling farther from office to dialysis unit were associated with greater odds of influenza vaccination.
Several characteristics of physicians seeing incident outpatient hemodialysis patients were associated with hospitalization and quality of care, but none with mortality.
背景/目的:在多个医学领域,医生的特征与质量指标表现及患者预后存在差异相关。我们旨在确定为透析患者提供护理的医生的特征是否与患者预后相关。
这项队列研究使用了美国肾脏数据系统中2003年10月1日至2006年9月30日期间开始接受中心血液透析的患者的数据(n = 91,276)。定义了患者特征,并从血液透析第4至6个月期间提交的B部分医疗保险门诊透析服务索赔中识别出医生。医生特征来自美国医学协会医生主文件。使用Cox比例风险分析确定医生特征与患者1年死亡率和首次住院的关联;使用逻辑回归确定与护理质量(由流感疫苗接种和肾脏移植等待名单定义)的关联。
医生特征与患者死亡率无关。在对患者和其他提供者特征进行调整后,其医生从业时间较长或从事行政、研究或教学工作的患者住院的可能性更大;其提供者在较小的大都市统计区(MSA)执业的患者住院可能性较小。培训后时间越长,进入等待名单的机会越大,在较小的MSA执业则机会越小。毕业于外国医学院、在较小的MSA执业以及从办公室到透析单位的距离更远与流感疫苗接种的几率更高相关。
诊治初诊门诊血液透析患者的医生的几个特征与住院率和护理质量相关,但与死亡率无关。