Betz Marian E, Jones Jacqueline, Genco Emma, Carr David B, DiGuiseppi Carolyn, Haukoos Jason S, Lowenstein Steven R, Schwartz Robert
Department of Emergency Medicine, University of Colorado School of Medicine, Aurora. Department of Epidemiology, Colorado School of Public Health, Aurora.
College of Nursing, University of Colorado, Anschutz Medical Campus, Aurora.
Gerontologist. 2016 Apr;56(2):272-81. doi: 10.1093/geront/gnu038. Epub 2014 May 2.
Widespread screening of older drivers, with in-depth evaluation only of those who screen positive ("tiered assessment"), might efficiently balance driver safety and mobility. To inform program development, we sought to examine the perspectives of older drivers and clinicians on the concept of tiered assessment in primary care settings.
Iterative focus groups and interviews with 33 community-dwelling current drivers aged ≥65 years and 8 primary care providers. We used inductive and deductive theme analysis to explore driver and clinician perspectives and to identify barriers and facilitators to establishing a tiered older driver assessment program in primary care settings.
Four dominant themes emerged. Two themes addressed the overall concept: (a) support for the concept of tiered older driver assessment and (b) concerns about the consequences of older driver assessment and how these could affect program viability. Two themes addressed screening: (c) tension inherent in using a generalized approach to the highly individualized issue of driving and (d) logistical considerations for screening in primary care settings.
Standardized older driver screening and referral might improve clinician-driver communication, but screening should occur in a context that includes personalized mobility counseling.
对老年驾驶员进行广泛筛查,仅对筛查呈阳性者进行深入评估(“分层评估”),可能有效地平衡驾驶员安全与出行。为指导项目开发,我们试图考察老年驾驶员和临床医生对基层医疗环境中分层评估概念的看法。
对33名年龄≥65岁的社区现职驾驶员和8名基层医疗服务提供者进行迭代焦点小组访谈。我们采用归纳和演绎主题分析法来探究驾驶员和临床医生的观点,并确定在基层医疗环境中建立分层老年驾驶员评估项目的障碍和促进因素。
出现了四个主要主题。两个主题涉及总体概念:(a)对分层老年驾驶员评估概念的支持,以及(b)对老年驾驶员评估后果及其如何影响项目可行性的担忧。另外两个主题涉及筛查:(c)在针对高度个性化的驾驶问题采用通用方法时存在的内在矛盾,以及(d)基层医疗环境中筛查的后勤考量。
标准化的老年驾驶员筛查和转诊可能会改善临床医生与驾驶员之间的沟通,但筛查应在包含个性化出行咨询的背景下进行。