Division of Neuroscience, New England Primate Research Center, Harvard Medical School Southborough, MA, USA.
Front Hum Neurosci. 2014 May 6;8:283. doi: 10.3389/fnhum.2014.00283. eCollection 2014.
Many psychiatric diseases observed in humans have tenuous or absent analogs in other species. Most notable among these are schizophrenia and autism. One hypothesis has posited that these diseases have arisen as a consequence of human brain evolution, for example, that the same processes that led to advances in cognition, language, and executive function also resulted in novel diseases in humans when dysfunctional. Here, the molecular evolution of the protein-coding regions of genes associated with these and other psychiatric disorders are compared among species. Genes associated with psychiatric disorders are drawn from the literature and orthologous sequences are collected from eleven primate species (human, chimpanzee, bonobo, gorilla, orangutan, gibbon, macaque, baboon, marmoset, squirrel monkey, and galago) and 34 non-primate mammalian species. Evolutionary parameters, including dN/dS, are calculated for each gene and compared between disease classes and among species, focusing on humans and primates compared to other mammals, and on large-brained taxa (cetaceans, rhinoceros, walrus, bear, and elephant) compared to their small-brained sister species. Evidence of differential selection in humans to the exclusion of non-human primates was absent, however elevated dN/dS was detected in catarrhines as a whole, as well as in cetaceans, possibly as part of a more general trend. Although this may suggest that protein changes associated with schizophrenia and autism are not a cost of the higher brain function found in humans, it may also point to insufficiencies in the study of these diseases including incomplete or inaccurate gene association lists and/or a greater role of regulatory changes or copy number variation. Through this work a better understanding of the molecular evolution of the human brain, the pathophysiology of disease, and the genetic basis of human psychiatric disease is gained.
许多在人类中观察到的精神疾病在其他物种中仅有微弱或不存在的类似物。其中最显著的是精神分裂症和自闭症。一种假设认为,这些疾病是人类大脑进化的结果,例如,导致认知、语言和执行功能进步的相同过程,在出现功能障碍时也导致了人类的新疾病。在这里,比较了与这些和其他精神障碍相关的基因的蛋白质编码区域的分子进化。从文献中提取与精神障碍相关的基因,并从 11 种灵长类物种(人类、黑猩猩、倭黑猩猩、大猩猩、猩猩、长臂猿、猕猴、狒狒、绒猴、松鼠猴和夜猴)和 34 种非灵长类哺乳动物物种中收集同源序列。为每个基因计算进化参数,包括 dN/dS,并在疾病类别之间以及在物种之间进行比较,重点是与其他哺乳动物相比的人类和灵长类动物,以及与大脑较小的姐妹物种相比的大脑较大的分类群(鲸目动物、犀牛、海象、熊和大象)。尽管 catarrhines 中以及鲸目动物中可能存在更普遍的趋势,但没有证据表明人类中存在排除非灵长类动物的选择差异,但是检测到 dN/dS 升高,这可能是大脑功能更高的一部分。尽管这可能表明与精神分裂症和自闭症相关的蛋白质变化不是人类发现的更高大脑功能的代价,但也可能表明这些疾病的研究存在不足,包括不完全或不准确的基因关联列表,以及/或调节变化或拷贝数变异的更大作用。通过这项工作,人们对人类大脑的分子进化、疾病的病理生理学以及人类精神疾病的遗传基础有了更好的理解。