Juniper E F, Kline P A, Hargreave F E, Dolovich J
Department of Medicine, St. Joseph's Hospital, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
J Allergy Clin Immunol. 1989 Mar;83(3):627-33. doi: 10.1016/0091-6749(89)90075-4.
The clinical efficacy and side effect of (1) beclomethasone dipropionate aqueous nasal spray, 400 micrograms daily, (2) astemizole, 10 mg daily, and (3) beclomethasone, 400 micrograms, plus astemizole, 10 mg daily, were compared in a double-blind, randomized, parallel-group trial. Ninety adults were matched into groups of three according to sensitivity to ragweed pollen. One of each of the three subjects was assigned to nasal spray alone, one was assigned to astemizole alone, and one subject was assigned to both medications. Medications were started 1 week before and continued daily until 1 week after the ragweed-pollen season (6 weeks). If rhinoconjunctivitis was inadequately controlled with the trial medications, pressurized steroid nasal spray and/or antihistamine-decongestant eye drops were used in the minimum dose that would ensure relief. Nose and eye symptoms and concomitant medication use were recorded daily in a diary. Sneezing, nasal obstruction, and rhinorrhea were significantly better, and less additional nasal spray was used in subjects taking beclomethasone alone than in subjects taking astemizole alone. Beclomethasone plus astemizole provided no better control of rhinitis than beclomethasone alone. Eye symptoms and eye drop use tended to be less in subjects taking astemizole alone than in subjects taking beclomethasone alone, but the best control of eye symptoms was recorded in the subjects taking both trial medications. Side effects were mild or transient.
在一项双盲、随机、平行组试验中,比较了(1)每日400微克二丙酸倍氯米松水性鼻喷雾剂、(2)每日10毫克阿司咪唑和(3)每日400微克倍氯米松加10毫克阿司咪唑的临床疗效和副作用。90名成年人根据对豚草花粉的敏感性被分成三人一组。每组中的三人分别被分配单独使用鼻喷雾剂、单独使用阿司咪唑以及同时使用两种药物。在豚草花粉季节开始前1周开始用药,并持续每日用药至花粉季节结束后1周(共6周)。如果试验药物未能充分控制鼻结膜炎,则使用能确保缓解的最小剂量的加压类固醇鼻喷雾剂和/或抗组胺减充血剂眼药水。每天在日记中记录鼻和眼症状以及伴随用药情况。单独使用倍氯米松的受试者打喷嚏、鼻塞和流涕症状明显改善,且使用的额外鼻喷雾剂比单独使用阿司咪唑的受试者少。倍氯米松加阿司咪唑对鼻炎的控制效果并不比单独使用倍氯米松更好。单独使用阿司咪唑的受试者的眼部症状和眼药水使用量往往比单独使用倍氯米松的受试者少,但同时使用两种试验药物的受试者对眼部症状的控制效果最佳。副作用轻微或短暂。