Pavlovic Dragana M, Vértes Petra E, Bullmore Edward T, Schafer William R, Nichols Thomas E
Department of Statistics and Warwick Manufacturing Group, University of Warwick, Coventry, United Kingdom.
Brain Mapping Unit, Behavioural and Clinical Neuroscience Institute, Department of Psychiatry, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, United Kingdom.
PLoS One. 2014 Jul 2;9(7):e97584. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0097584. eCollection 2014.
Recently, there has been much interest in the community structure or mesoscale organization of complex networks. This structure is characterised either as a set of sparsely inter-connected modules or as a highly connected core with a sparsely connected periphery. However, it is often difficult to disambiguate these two types of mesoscale structure or, indeed, to summarise the full network in terms of the relationships between its mesoscale constituents. Here, we estimate a community structure with a stochastic blockmodel approach, the Erdős-Rényi Mixture Model, and compare it to the much more widely used deterministic methods, such as the Louvain and Spectral algorithms. We used the Caenorhabditis elegans (C. elegans) nervous system (connectome) as a model system in which biological knowledge about each node or neuron can be used to validate the functional relevance of the communities obtained. The deterministic algorithms derived communities with 4-5 modules, defined by sparse inter-connectivity between all modules. In contrast, the stochastic Erdős-Rényi Mixture Model estimated a community with 9 blocks or groups which comprised a similar set of modules but also included a clearly defined core, made of 2 small groups. We show that the "core-in-modules" decomposition of the worm brain network, estimated by the Erdős-Rényi Mixture Model, is more compatible with prior biological knowledge about the C. elegans nervous system than the purely modular decomposition defined deterministically. We also show that the blockmodel can be used both to generate stochastic realisations (simulations) of the biological connectome, and to compress network into a small number of super-nodes and their connectivity. We expect that the Erdős-Rényi Mixture Model may be useful for investigating the complex community structures in other (nervous) systems.
最近,复杂网络的社区结构或中尺度组织引起了广泛关注。这种结构的特征要么是一组稀疏互连的模块,要么是一个高度连接的核心与一个稀疏连接的外围。然而,通常很难区分这两种类型的中尺度结构,或者实际上很难根据其组成部分之间的关系来总结整个网络。在这里,我们使用随机块模型方法(即厄多斯-雷尼混合模型)估计社区结构,并将其与使用更为广泛的确定性方法(如鲁汶算法和谱算法)进行比较。我们使用秀丽隐杆线虫的神经系统(连接体)作为模型系统,其中关于每个节点或神经元的生物学知识可用于验证所获得社区的功能相关性。确定性算法得出的社区有4 - 5个模块,所有模块之间通过稀疏互连来定义。相比之下,随机的厄多斯-雷尼混合模型估计出一个有9个块或组的社区,它包含一组类似的模块,但也包括一个由2个小群体组成的明确定义的核心。我们表明,由厄多斯-雷尼混合模型估计的线虫脑网络的“模块内核心”分解比确定性定义的纯模块分解更符合关于秀丽隐杆线虫神经系统的现有生物学知识。我们还表明,块模型既可以用于生成生物连接体的随机实现(模拟),也可以将网络压缩为少数几个超级节点及其连接性。我们预计厄多斯-雷尼混合模型可能有助于研究其他(神经)系统中的复杂社区结构。