Heydari Gholam Reza, Ramezankhani Ali, Talischi Firoozeh
Tobacco Prevention and Control Research Center, NRITLD, TEHRAN-IRAN.
School of Public Health, Shahid Beheshti University of Medical Sciences, TEHRAN-IRAN.
Tanaffos. 2011;10(1):40-7.
Cigarette smoking is considered the first preventable cause of death in the world. Social, familial, and personal factors play an important role in prevention or cessation of smoking. Educating the public in order to enhance their knowledge, change their attitude and improve their habits is also effective in this respect. In 2007, the executive protocol of the Comprehensive Law on Smoking Control was compiled in the Ministry of Health and according to the Article 5 of this law pictorial health warning labels had to be applied on cigarette packaging. This study was designed and conducted in 2 phases of before and 9 months after the implementation of this law and evaluated the effect of it on smokers' knowledge, attitude and pattern of smoking.
This was a cross-sectional descriptive study conducted to evaluate the effect of cigarette packs' pictorial health warning labels on the knowledge, attitude and smoking pattern of smokers residing in Tehran. After calculating the size of understudy population and estimation of the exclusions, 1731 subjects were randomly selected using the multiphase cluster method from the 22 districts of Tehran. Data were collected using a questionnaire designed according to the standard questionnaire of the World Health Organization (WHO) and International Union Against Tuberculosis and Lung Disease (IUATLD). Qualitative and quantitative value and reliability of the variables including cigarette consumption, knowledge about the law, and pattern of smoking were evaluated in 2 phases and the quality of pictures and their effects on the mentioned variables were assessed in the 2(nd) phase.
Before adopting the pictorial warning labels in the first phase of the study, 1731 respondents were evaluated out of which 71.8% were males and 28.2% were females. These cases had an average of 17.6±12.3 years history of smoking. A total of 38% (675 subjects) used Iranian cigarette brands and 39.5% were aware of the implementation of pictorial health warning labels on cigarette packs. In terms of smokers' attitude towards the implementation of this law, they mostly had no opinion about it. A total of 33.3% stated that they may cut down on smoking as the result of this law. Men had a higher percentage of smoking a cigarette first thing in the morning before breakfast and women had a higher rate of consuming foreign cigarette brands (P < 0.001). In the second phase of the study, 1590 cases of the phase 1 subjects participated. Subjects had a significantly higher knowledge about the implementation of pictorial health warning labels on cigarette packs (P < 0.001). Attitude towards this law did not change significantly compared to the first phase although the mean score improved by 0.07%. Enforcement of this law resulted in decreased consumption in 7.6% of the participants. However, the Wilcoxon test did not show any significant difference. In terms of the quality of pictures, 61.6% had no opinion, and 28.7% expressed that the pictures had poor quality. No significant difference was observed between the Iranian or foreign brands in terms of smoking rate after applying the pictorial warning labels.
We believed that the smoking rate would decrease after applying the pictorial health warning labels on cigarette packs. However, it did not happen. Also, adopting these labels did not have a significant effect on smokers changing their favorite brand from Iranian to foreign brands or vice versa. Type and quality of pictures require major revision and corrections.
吸烟被认为是全球首要的可预防死因。社会、家庭和个人因素在预防或戒烟方面发挥着重要作用。在这方面,对公众进行教育以增强其知识、改变其态度并改善其习惯也很有效。2007年,卫生部编制了《控烟综合法》的执行议定书,根据该法律第5条,必须在香烟包装上张贴图片健康警示标签。本研究分两个阶段设计并开展,分别在该法律实施前及实施9个月后进行,评估其对吸烟者知识、态度和吸烟模式的影响。
这是一项横断面描述性研究,旨在评估香烟包装上的图片健康警示标签对德黑兰吸烟者的知识、态度和吸烟模式的影响。在计算研究对象数量并估计排除人数后,采用多阶段整群抽样方法从德黑兰的22个区中随机选取了1731名受试者。使用根据世界卫生组织(WHO)和国际防痨和肺部疾病联盟(IUATLD)的标准问卷设计的问卷收集数据。在两个阶段评估包括香烟消费、对法律的了解以及吸烟模式等变量的定性和定量值及可靠性,并在第二阶段评估图片质量及其对上述变量的影响。
在研究的第一阶段采用图片警示标签之前,对1731名受访者进行了评估,其中71.8%为男性,28.2%为女性。这些受试者的吸烟史平均为17.6±12.3年。共有38%(675名受试者)使用伊朗香烟品牌,39.5%的人知晓在香烟包装上实施图片健康警示标签。就吸烟者对该法律实施的态度而言,他们大多对此没有看法。共有33.3%的人表示他们可能会因这项法律而减少吸烟。男性在早餐前第一件事就是吸烟的比例较高,女性消费外国香烟品牌的比例较高(P<0.001)。在研究的第二阶段,第一阶段的1590名受试者参与。受试者对在香烟包装上实施图片健康警示标签的了解显著提高(P<0.001)。与第一阶段相比,对该法律的态度虽平均得分提高了0.07%,但没有显著变化。这项法律的实施导致7.6%的参与者吸烟量减少。然而,威尔科克森检验未显示任何显著差异。就图片质量而言,61.6%的人没有看法,28.7%的人表示图片质量差。在应用图片警示标签后,伊朗或外国品牌在吸烟率方面未观察到显著差异。
我们认为在香烟包装上应用图片健康警示标签后吸烟率会下降。然而,并未出现这种情况。此外,采用这些标签对吸烟者将其喜爱的品牌从伊朗品牌换成外国品牌或反之亦无显著影响。图片的类型和质量需要大幅修改和校正。