Welch Janet L, Johnson Michelle, Zimmerman Lani, Russell Cynthia L, Perkins Susan M, Decker Brian S
Indiana University, Indianapolis, USA
University of Nebraska Medical Center, Lincoln, USA.
West J Nurs Res. 2015 May;37(5):652-78. doi: 10.1177/0193945914551007. Epub 2014 Sep 18.
The prevalence, effect on health outcomes, and economic impact of chronic kidney disease (CKD) have created interest in self-management interventions to help slow disease progression to kidney failure. Seven studies were reviewed to identify knowledge gaps and future directions for research. All studies were published between 2010 and 2013; no investigations were conducted in the United States. Knowledge gaps included the focus on medical self-management tasks with no attention to role or emotional tasks, lack of family involvement during intervention delivery, and an inability to form conclusions about the efficacy of interventions because methodological rigor was insufficient. Educational content varied across studies. Strategies to improve self-management skills and enhance self-efficacy varied and were limited in scope. Further development and testing of theory-based interventions are warranted. There is a critical need for future research using well-designed trials with appropriately powered sample sizes, well-tested instruments, and clear and consistent reporting of results.
慢性肾脏病(CKD)的患病率、对健康结局的影响以及经济影响引发了人们对自我管理干预措施的兴趣,以帮助减缓疾病进展至肾衰竭。对七项研究进行了综述,以确定知识空白和未来的研究方向。所有研究均发表于2010年至2013年之间;美国未开展相关调查。知识空白包括:专注于医疗自我管理任务,而未关注角色或情感任务;干预实施过程中缺乏家庭参与;由于方法学严谨性不足,无法就干预措施的疗效得出结论。各研究的教育内容各不相同。提高自我管理技能和增强自我效能的策略各不相同且范围有限。有必要进一步开发和测试基于理论的干预措施。迫切需要未来开展设计良好的试验,采用样本量充足、经过充分测试的工具,并清晰一致地报告结果。