Johnson June Felice, Bell Edward, Bottenberg Michelle, Eastman Darla, Grady Sarah, Koenigsfeld Carrie, Maki Erik, Meyer Kristin, Phillips Chuck, Schirmer Lori
Drake University College of Pharmacy and Health Sciences, Des Moines, Iowa.
Fort Sanders Regional Medical Center, Knoxville, Tennessee ; Author affiliation at time of study was Drake University.
Am J Pharm Educ. 2014 Sep 15;78(7):142. doi: 10.5688/ajpe787142.
To evaluate the impact of team-based learning (TBL) in a pharmacotherapeutics course on pharmacy students' ratings of faculty instructors and the course, and to assess students' performance after implementation of team-taught TBL.
Teaching methodology in a pharmacotherapeutics course was changed from a lecture with recitation approach in 2 semesters of a 6 credit-hour course to a TBL framework in a 3-semester 3+4+5 credit hour course. The distribution of faculty of instruction was changed from 4 faculty members per week to 1 faculty per 1-credit-hour module. TBL consisted of preclass study preparation, readiness assurance (Individual Readiness Assessment Test and Group Readiness Assessment Test), and in-class application exercises requiring simultaneous team responses.
Retrospective analysis of student ratings of faculty and instructional methods was conducted for the 2 years pre-TBL and 4 years during TBL. Final course grades were evaluated during the same time period. Student ratings showed progressive improvements over 4 years after the introduction of team-based learning. When aggregated, ratings in the "excellent teacher" category were unchanged with TBL compared to pre-TBL. Improvements in faculty instructor approaches to teaching were noted during TBL. Group grades were consistently higher than individual grades, and aggregate course grades were similar to those prior to TBL implementation.
Implementation of TBL in a pharmacotherapeutics course series demonstrated the value of team performance over individual performance, indicated positive student perceptions of teaching approaches by course faculty, and resulted in comparable student performance in final course grades compared to the previous teaching method.
评估基于团队的学习(TBL)在药物治疗学课程中对药学专业学生对教师和课程评分的影响,并评估团队授课的TBL实施后学生的表现。
在一门6学分课程的两个学期中,药物治疗学课程的教学方法从讲授加背诵法改为一门3学期、3+4+5学分课程中的TBL框架。授课教师的分配从每周4名教师改为每1学分模块1名教师。TBL包括课前学习准备、准备情况保证(个人准备情况评估测试和小组准备情况评估测试)以及需要团队同时作答的课堂应用练习。
对TBL实施前2年和TBL实施期间4年学生对教师和教学方法的评分进行回顾性分析。在同一时期评估课程最终成绩。引入基于团队的学习后,学生评分在4年中逐步提高。汇总后,与TBL实施前相比,“优秀教师”类别的评分没有变化。在TBL实施期间,注意到教师教学方法有所改进。小组成绩始终高于个人成绩,课程总成绩与TBL实施前相似。
在药物治疗学课程系列中实施TBL证明了团队表现优于个人表现的价值,表明学生对课程教师的教学方法有积极的看法,并且与之前的教学方法相比,学生在课程最终成绩中的表现相当。