Nery Joilda Silva, Pereira Susan Martins, Rasella Davide, Penna Maria Lúcia Fernandes, Aquino Rosana, Rodrigues Laura Cunha, Barreto Mauricio Lima, Penna Gerson Oliveira
Federal University of Bahia, Institute of Collective Health, Salvador, Bahia, Brazil.
Fluminense Federal University, Health Sciences Center, Institute of Community Health, Niterói, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil.
PLoS Negl Trop Dis. 2014 Nov 20;8(11):e3357. doi: 10.1371/journal.pntd.0003357. eCollection 2014 Nov.
Social determinants can affect the transmission of leprosy and its progression to disease. Not much is known about the effectiveness of welfare and primary health care policies on the reduction of leprosy occurrence. The aim of this study is to evaluate the impact of the Brazilian cash transfer (Bolsa Família Program-BFP) and primary health care (Family Health Program-FHP) programs on new case detection rate of leprosy.
METHODOLOGY/PRINCIPAL FINDINGS: We conducted the study with a mixed ecological design, a combination of an ecological multiple-group and time-trend design in the period 2004-2011 with the Brazilian municipalities as unit of analysis. The main independent variables were the BFP and FHP coverage at the municipal level and the outcome was new case detection rate of leprosy. Leprosy new cases, BFP and FHP coverage, population and other relevant socio-demographic covariates were obtained from national databases. We used fixed-effects negative binomial models for panel data adjusted for relevant socio-demographic covariates. A total of 1,358 municipalities were included in the analysis. In the studied period, while the municipal coverage of BFP and FHP increased, the new case detection rate of leprosy decreased. Leprosy new case detection rate was significantly reduced in municipalities with consolidated BFP coverage (Risk Ratio 0.79; 95% CI =0.74-0.83) and significantly increased in municipalities with FHP coverage in the medium (72-95%) (Risk Ratio 1.05; 95% CI =1.02-1.09) and higher coverage tertiles (>95%) (Risk Ratio 1.12; 95% CI =1.08-1.17).
At the same time the Family Health Program had been effective in increasing the new case detection rate of leprosy in Brazil, the Bolsa Família Program was associated with a reduction of the new case detection rate of leprosy that we propose reflects a reduction in leprosy incidence.
社会决定因素可影响麻风病的传播及其向疾病的进展。关于福利和初级卫生保健政策在降低麻风病发病率方面的有效性,人们了解得并不多。本研究的目的是评估巴西现金转移支付计划(家庭补助金计划 - BFP)和初级卫生保健计划(家庭健康计划 - FHP)对麻风病新病例发现率的影响。
方法/主要发现:我们采用混合生态设计进行了这项研究,这是一种生态多组和时间趋势设计的组合,研究期为2004 - 2011年,以巴西各市为分析单位。主要自变量是市级层面的BFP和FHP覆盖率,结果变量是麻风病新病例发现率。麻风病新病例、BFP和FHP覆盖率、人口以及其他相关社会人口协变量均来自国家数据库。我们使用固定效应负二项模型对面板数据进行分析,并对相关社会人口协变量进行了调整。分析共纳入1358个市。在研究期间,虽然BFP和FHP的市级覆盖率有所提高,但麻风病新病例发现率却有所下降。在BFP覆盖率巩固的市,麻风病新病例发现率显著降低(风险比0.79;95%置信区间=0.74 - 0.83),而在FHP覆盖率处于中等水平(72 - 95%)(风险比1.05;95%置信区间=1.02 - 1.09)和较高水平三分位数(>95%)(风险比1.12;95%置信区间=1.08 - 1.17)的市,新病例发现率显著增加。
在家庭健康计划有效提高巴西麻风病新病例发现率的同时,家庭补助金计划与麻风病新病例发现率的降低相关,我们认为这反映了麻风病发病率的下降。