Aubel Olivier, Ohl Fabien
ISSUL, Faculté des sciences sociales et politiques, Université de Lausanne, Géopolis, 1015 Lausanne, Switzerland(1).
ISSUL, Faculté des sciences sociales et politiques, Université de Lausanne, Géopolis, 1015 Lausanne, Switzerland(1).
Int J Drug Policy. 2014 Nov;25(6):1094-102. doi: 10.1016/j.drugpo.2014.08.010. Epub 2014 Sep 6.
Framed by an overly reductionist perspective on doping in professional cycling as an individual moral failing, anti-doping policies tend to envisage a combination of education and repression as the primary intervention strategies. We offer an alternative approach, which seeks to understand doping practices as embedded in social relations, especially in relation to team organisation and employment conditions.
We undertake an in-depth analysis of the functioning of nine of the 40 world professional cycling teams, and the careers of the 2,351 riders who were or have been professionals since 2005.
We find that anti-doping approaches rest upon questionable assumptions of doping as an individual moral fault, and have not produced the anti-doping effects expected or intended. Based on an analysis of team practices, and the ways in which riders produce their achievements, we offer an alternative perspective which emphasises doping as a product of social-economic condition. Our findings emphasise employment and business models, as well as day-to-day working conditions, as structural drivers of doping practices in which individuals and teams engage.
Anti-doping requires structural as well as cultural change within the sport of professional cycling, especially in the ways teams function economically.
反兴奋剂政策往往将职业自行车运动中的使用兴奋剂问题框定为个人道德缺失,这是一种过于简化的观点,倾向于将教育和压制相结合作为主要干预策略。我们提供一种替代方法,试图将使用兴奋剂行为理解为嵌入社会关系之中,特别是与团队组织和就业条件相关的关系。
我们对40支世界职业自行车队中的9支队伍的运作情况,以及自2005年以来曾是或仍是职业车手的2351名车手的职业生涯进行了深入分析。
我们发现,反兴奋剂方法基于将使用兴奋剂视为个人道德过错这一有问题的假设,并未产生预期或想要达到的反兴奋剂效果。基于对团队实践以及车手取得成绩的方式的分析,我们提供了一种替代观点,强调使用兴奋剂是社会经济状况的产物。我们的研究结果强调就业和商业模式以及日常工作条件,是个人和团队参与的使用兴奋剂行为的结构性驱动因素。
职业自行车运动中的反兴奋剂需要在结构和文化方面进行变革,特别是在团队的经济运作方式上。