Kang Sung Gu, Ryu Byung Ju, Yang Kyung Sook, Ko Young Hwii, Cho Seok, Kang Seok Ho, Patel Vipul R, Cheon Jun
Department of Urology, Korea University School of Medicine, Seoul, Republic of Korea.
Department of Rehabilitation Medicine, SahmYook Medical Center, Seoul, Republic of Korea.
J Surg Educ. 2015 May-Jun;72(3):369-76. doi: 10.1016/j.jsurg.2014.06.023. Epub 2014 Dec 4.
A robotic virtual reality simulator (Mimic dV-Trainer) can be a useful training method for the da Vinci surgical system. Herein, we investigate several repetitive training schedules and determine which is the most effective.
A total of 30 medical students were enrolled and were divided into 3 groups according to the training schedule. Group 1 performed the task 1 hour daily for 4 consecutive days, group II performed the task on once per week for 1 hour for 4 consecutive weeks, and group III performed the task for 4 consecutive hours in 1 day. The effects of training were investigated by analyzing the number of repetitions and the time required to complete the "Tube 2" simulation task when the learning curve plateau was reached. The point at which participants reached a stable score was evaluated using the cumulative sum control graph.
The average time to complete the task at the learning curve plateau was 150.3 seconds in group I, 171.9 seconds in group II, and 188.5 seconds in group III. The number of task repetitions required to reach the learning curve plateau was 45 repetitions in group I, 36 repetitions in group II, and 39 repetitions in group III. Therefore, there was continuous improvement in the time required to perform the task after 40 repetitions in group I only. There was a significant correlation between improvement in each trial interval and attempt, and the correlation coefficient (0.924) in group I was higher than that in group II (0.899) and group III (0.838).
Daily 1-hour practice sessions performed for 4 consecutive days resulted in the best final score, continuous score improvement, and effective training while minimizing fatigue. This repetition schedule can be used for effectively training novices in future.
机器人虚拟现实模拟器(Mimic dV-Trainer)对于达芬奇手术系统而言可能是一种有用的训练方法。在此,我们研究了几种重复训练方案,并确定哪种方案最有效。
共招募了30名医学生,并根据训练方案将他们分为3组。第1组连续4天每天执行任务1小时,第2组连续4周每周执行任务1小时,第3组在1天内连续执行任务4小时。通过分析达到学习曲线平台期时完成“Tube 2”模拟任务的重复次数和所需时间来研究训练效果。使用累积和控制图评估参与者达到稳定分数的时间点。
在学习曲线平台期,第1组完成任务的平均时间为150.3秒,第2组为171.9秒,第3组为188.5秒。达到学习曲线平台期所需的任务重复次数,第1组为45次,第2组为36次,第3组为39次。因此,仅第1组在40次重复后执行任务所需的时间持续改善。每个试验间隔的改善与尝试次数之间存在显著相关性,第1组的相关系数(0.924)高于第2组(0.899)和第3组(0.838)。
连续4天每天进行1小时的练习可获得最佳的最终成绩、持续的成绩提高以及有效的训练,同时将疲劳降至最低。这种重复训练方案未来可用于有效培训新手。