de Klerk N H, Cookson W O, Musk A W, Armstrong B K, Glancy J J
National Health and Medical Research Council Unit in Epidemiology and Preventive Medicine, University of Western Australia.
Br J Ind Med. 1989 Jul;46(7):461-7. doi: 10.1136/oem.46.7.461.
Serial plain chest radiographs of 384 men who worked at the Wittenoom crocidolite mine and mill between 1943 and 1966 and who applied for pneumoconiosis compensation between 1948 and 1982 have been examined independently by two trained observers for pleural disease using the 1980 ILO-UICC classification of radiographs to record width and extent of pleural disease. Radiographs covering follow up periods of from two to 38 years were examined (median number of films per subject was nine). The degree of crocidolite exposure was estimated from employment records and a survey of airborne fibre concentrations performed in 1966. Agreement between the observers on the presence and degree of pleural disease in the final film for each subject was moderately close (Kendall's tau B = 0.62) and was least for subjects with thickening less than 5 mm in width. Diffuse pleural thickening extending for greater than 50% of the lateral chest wall was the most common type recorded by both observers. Minor pleural thickening frequently progressed in extent along the lateral chest wall but progression beyond 5 mm in thickness was less common. Pleural plaques were not seen to progress beyond their initial thickness or extent. The rate of onset of thickening in this population increased continually from the time of first exposure and also increased slightly with age. There was evidence that the level of total cumulative exposure to crocidolite increased the rate of onset of pleural thickening in the period between five and 15 years after first exposure. Rate of progression of established thickening was greatest in subjects who first developed thickening early after first exposure. The relative rate of progression decreased slowly with time from first signs of thickening and there was no evidence of any progression more than 15 years after onset.
对384名男性的系列胸部X线平片进行了检查,这些男性在1943年至1966年间曾在维特努姆青石棉矿和工厂工作,并在1948年至1982年间申请尘肺病补偿。两名经过培训的观察者使用1980年国际劳工组织-国际癌症研究机构的X线片分类法,独立检查这些X线片以确定胸膜疾病,记录胸膜疾病的宽度和范围。对随访时间为2至38年的X线片进行了检查(每位受试者的X线片中位数为9张)。根据就业记录和1966年进行的空气中纤维浓度调查,估算了青石棉暴露程度。两位观察者对每位受试者最后一张X线片中胸膜疾病的存在情况和程度的一致性为中等程度接近(肯德尔tau B系数=0.62),对于宽度增厚小于5毫米的受试者,一致性最低。两名观察者记录的最常见类型是弥漫性胸膜增厚,延伸超过侧胸壁的50%。轻度胸膜增厚通常沿侧胸壁范围进展,但厚度超过5毫米的进展较少见。未见胸膜斑超过其初始厚度或范围进展。该人群中增厚的发病速率从首次暴露时开始持续增加,且也随年龄略有增加。有证据表明,在首次暴露后的5至15年期间,青石棉的总累积暴露水平增加了胸膜增厚的发病速率。在首次暴露后早期就出现增厚的受试者中,已形成增厚的进展速率最大。从增厚的最初迹象开始,相对进展速率随时间缓慢下降,且没有证据表明发病后15年以上有任何进展。