Purdue Mark P, Hutchings Sally J, Rushton Lesley, Silverman Debra T
Occupational and Environmental Epidemiology Branch, Division of Cancer Epidemiology and Genetics, National Cancer Institute, Bethesda, MD; Ontario Institute for Cancer Research, Toronto, Canada.
Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, School of Public Health and MRC-HPA Centre for Environment and Health, Imperial College London, London, UK.
Ann Epidemiol. 2015 Mar;25(3):188-92. doi: 10.1016/j.annepidem.2014.11.009. Epub 2014 Nov 13.
To review the literature on the estimation of the population attributable fraction (PAF) of cancer due to occupational exposures and to describe challenges in the estimation of this metric. To help illustrate the inherent challenges, we also estimate PAFs for selected cancers diagnosed in the United States in 2010 attributable to work as a painter (causally associated with bladder and lung cancer) and shift work (possibly associated with breast cancer).
We reviewed and summarized previous reports providing quantitative estimates of PAF for total cancer due to occupational exposures. We calculated PAF estimates for painters and shift work using methodology from a detailed investigation of the occupational cancer burden in Great Britain, with adaptations made for the US population.
The estimated occupation-attributable fraction for total cancer generally ranged between 2% and 8% (men, 3%-14%; women, 1%-2%) based on previous reports. We calculated that employment as a painter accounted for a very small proportion of cancers of the bladder and lung diagnosed in the United States in 2010, with PAFs of 0.5% for each site. In contrast, our calculations suggest that the potential impact of shift work on breast cancer (if causal) could be substantial, with a PAF of 5.7%, translating to 11,777 attributable breast cancers.
Continued efforts to estimate the occupational cancer burden will be important as scientific evidence and economic trends evolve. Such projects should consider the challenges involved in PAF estimation, which we summarize in this report.
回顾关于职业暴露导致癌症的人群归因分数(PAF)估算的文献,并描述该指标估算中的挑战。为帮助说明内在挑战,我们还估算了2010年在美国诊断出的某些特定癌症的PAF,这些癌症分别归因于油漆工工作(与膀胱癌和肺癌有因果关联)和轮班工作(可能与乳腺癌有关)。
我们回顾并总结了先前提供职业暴露导致所有癌症PAF定量估算的报告。我们采用对英国职业癌症负担详细调查中的方法,并针对美国人群进行了调整,计算了油漆工和轮班工作的PAF估算值。
根据先前报告,所有癌症的职业归因分数估计值一般在2%至8%之间(男性为3% - 14%;女性为1% - 2%)。我们计算得出,2010年在美国诊断出的膀胱癌和肺癌中,油漆工职业导致的病例占比非常小,每个部位的PAF均为0.5%。相比之下,我们的计算表明,轮班工作对乳腺癌的潜在影响(如果存在因果关系)可能很大,PAF为5.7%,即归因于轮班工作的乳腺癌病例达11,777例。
随着科学证据和经济趋势的发展,持续努力估算职业癌症负担将很重要。此类项目应考虑PAF估算中涉及的挑战,我们在本报告中对此进行了总结。