Albert Steven M, King Jennifer, Keene Robert M
Department of Behavioral and Community Health Sciences, University of Pittsburgh, 130 Desoto Street, Pittsburgh, PA 15261, USA.
University Center for Social and Urban Research, 3343 Forbes Ave, Pittsburgh, PA 15260, USA.
Prev Med. 2015 Feb;71:31-6. doi: 10.1016/j.ypmed.2014.12.006. Epub 2014 Dec 13.
Interactive voice response (IVR) systems offer great advantages for data collection in large, geographically dispersed samples involving frequent contact. We assessed the quality of IVR data collected from older respondents participating in a statewide falls prevention program evaluation in Pennsylvania in 2010-12.
Participants (n=1834) were followed up monthly for up to 10 months to compare respondents who completed all, some, or no assessments in the IVR system. Validity was assessed by examining IVR-reported falls incidence relative to baseline in-person self-report and performance assessment of balance.
While a third of the sample switched from IVR to in-person calls over follow-up, IVR interviews were successfully used to complete 68.1% of completed monthly assessments (10,511/15,430). Switching to in-person interviews was not associated with measures of participant function or cognition. Both self-reported (p<.0001) and performance assessment of balance (p=.05) at baseline were related to falls incidence.
IVR is a productive modality for falls research among older adults. Future research should establish what level of initial personal research contact is optimal for boosting IVR completion rates and what research domains are most appropriate for this kind of contact.
交互式语音应答(IVR)系统在涉及频繁联系的大型、地理分布分散的样本数据收集中具有巨大优势。我们评估了2010 - 2012年从宾夕法尼亚州参与全州范围跌倒预防项目评估的老年受访者那里收集的IVR数据的质量。
对参与者(n = 1834)进行长达10个月的每月随访,以比较在IVR系统中完成了所有评估、部分评估或未完成任何评估的受访者。通过检查IVR报告的跌倒发生率相对于基线面对面自我报告以及平衡功能评估来评估有效性。
虽然三分之一的样本在随访期间从IVR转为面对面电话访谈,但IVR访谈成功用于完成了68.1%的每月完成评估(10511/15430)。转为面对面访谈与参与者功能或认知指标无关。基线时的自我报告(p <.0001)和平衡功能评估(p =.05)均与跌倒发生率相关。
IVR是老年人群跌倒研究的一种有效方式。未来研究应确定何种初始个人研究接触水平最有利于提高IVR完成率,以及哪些研究领域最适合这种接触方式。