Tree J A, Hall G, Pearson G, Rayner E, Graham V A, Steeds K, Bewley K R, Hatch G J, Dennis M, Taylor I, Roberts A D, Funnell S G P, Vipond J
Microbiological Services, Public Health England, Porton Down, Salisbury, Wiltshire, United Kingdom
Microbiological Services, Public Health England, Porton Down, Salisbury, Wiltshire, United Kingdom.
J Virol. 2015 Apr;89(8):4335-44. doi: 10.1128/JVI.03029-14. Epub 2015 Feb 4.
To evaluate new vaccines when human efficacy studies are not possible, the FDA's "Animal Rule" requires well-characterized models of infection. Thus, in the present study, the early pathogenic events of monkeypox infection in nonhuman primates, a surrogate for variola virus infection, were characterized. Cynomolgus macaques were exposed to aerosolized monkeypox virus (10(5) PFU). Clinical observations, viral loads, immune responses, and pathological changes were examined on days 2, 4, 6, 8, 10, and 12 postchallenge. Viral DNA (vDNA) was detected in the lungs on day 2 postchallenge, and viral antigen was detected, by immunostaining, in the epithelium of bronchi, bronchioles, and alveolar walls. Lesions comprised rare foci of dysplastic and sloughed cells in respiratory bronchioles. By day 4, vDNA was detected in the throat, tonsil, and spleen, and monkeypox antigen was detected in the lung, hilar and submandibular lymph nodes, spleen, and colon. Lung lesions comprised focal epithelial necrosis and inflammation. Body temperature peaked on day 6, pox lesions appeared on the skin, and lesions, with positive immunostaining, were present in the lung, tonsil, spleen, lymph nodes, and colon. By day 8, vDNA was present in 9/13 tissues. Blood concentrations of interleukin 1ra (IL-1ra), IL-6, and gamma interferon (IFN-γ) increased markedly. By day 10, circulating IgG antibody concentrations increased, and on day 12, animals showed early signs of recovery. These results define early events occurring in an inhalational macaque monkeypox infection model, supporting its use as a surrogate model for human smallpox.
Bioterrorism poses a major threat to public health, as the deliberate release of infectious agents, such smallpox or a related virus, monkeypox, would have catastrophic consequences. The development and testing of new medical countermeasures, e.g., vaccines, are thus priorities; however, tests for efficacy in humans cannot be performed because it would be unethical and field trials are not feasible. To overcome this, the FDA may grant marketing approval of a new product based upon the "Animal Rule," in which interventions are tested for efficacy in well-characterized animal models. Monkeypox virus infection of nonhuman primates (NHPs) presents a potential surrogate disease model for smallpox. Previously, the later stages of monkeypox infection were defined, but the early course of infection remains unstudied. Here, the early pathogenic events of inhalational monkeypox infection in NHPs were characterized, and the results support the use of this surrogate model for testing human smallpox interventions.
当无法进行人体疗效研究时,为评估新型疫苗,美国食品药品监督管理局(FDA)的“动物规则”要求使用特征明确的感染模型。因此,在本研究中,对非人灵长类动物(天花病毒感染的替代模型)猴痘感染的早期致病事件进行了特征描述。将食蟹猴暴露于雾化的猴痘病毒(10⁵ 空斑形成单位)。在攻毒后第2、4、6、8、10和12天检查临床观察结果、病毒载量、免疫反应和病理变化。攻毒后第2天在肺中检测到病毒DNA(vDNA),通过免疫染色在支气管、细支气管和肺泡壁上皮中检测到病毒抗原。病变包括呼吸性细支气管中罕见的发育异常和脱落细胞灶。到第4天,在咽喉、扁桃体和脾脏中检测到vDNA,在肺、肺门和下颌下淋巴结、脾脏和结肠中检测到猴痘抗原。肺部病变包括局灶性上皮坏死和炎症。体温在第6天达到峰值,皮肤出现痘疹病变,在肺、扁桃体、脾脏、淋巴结和结肠中存在免疫染色阳性的病变。到第8天,13个组织中有9个存在vDNA。白细胞介素1受体拮抗剂(IL-1ra)、IL-6和γ干扰素(IFN-γ)的血药浓度显著升高。到第10天,循环IgG抗体浓度升高,第12天动物显示出早期恢复迹象。这些结果确定了吸入性食蟹猴猴痘感染模型中发生的早期事件,支持将其用作人类天花的替代模型。
生物恐怖主义对公众健康构成重大威胁,因为故意释放诸如天花或相关病毒猴痘等传染源将产生灾难性后果。因此,开发和测试新的医学应对措施(如疫苗)是当务之急;然而,由于不道德且现场试验不可行,无法在人体中进行疗效测试。为克服这一问题,FDA可根据“动物规则”批准新产品上市,即在特征明确的动物模型中测试干预措施的疗效。非人灵长类动物(NHP)的猴痘病毒感染为天花提供了一种潜在的替代疾病模型。此前,已确定了猴痘感染的后期阶段,但感染的早期过程仍未得到研究。在此,对NHP吸入性猴痘感染的早期致病事件进行了特征描述,结果支持使用这种替代模型来测试人类天花干预措施。