Northoff Georg
Brain Imaging and Neuroethics Research Unit, Institute of Mental Health Research, Canada.
Int J Psychophysiol. 2016 May;103:174-84. doi: 10.1016/j.ijpsycho.2015.02.012. Epub 2015 Feb 9.
William James postulated a "stream of consciousness" that presupposes temporal continuity. The neuronal mechanisms underlying the construction of such temporal continuity remain unclear, however, in my contribution, I propose a neuro-phenomenal hypothesis that is based on slow cortical potentials and their extension of the present moment as described in the phenomenal term of "width of present". More specifically, I focus on the way the brain's neural activity needs to be encoded in order to make possible the "stream of consciousness." This leads us again to the low-frequency fluctuations of the brain's neural activity and more specifically to slow cortical potentials (SCPs). Due to their long phase duration as low-frequency fluctuations, SCPs can integrate different stimuli and their associated neural activity from different regions in one converging region. Such integration may be central for consciousness to occur, as it was recently postulated by He and Raichle. They leave open, however, the question of the exact neuronal mechanisms, like the encoding strategy, that make possible the association of the otherwise purely neuronal SCP with consciousness and its phenomenal features. I hypothesize that SCPs allow for linking and connecting different discrete points in physical time by encoding their statistically based temporal differences rather than the single discrete time points by themselves. This presupposes difference-based coding rather than stimulus-based coding. The encoding of such statistically based temporal differences makes it possible to "go beyond" the merely physical features of the stimuli; that is, their single discrete time points and their conduction delays (as related to their neural processing in the brain). This, in turn, makes possible the constitution of "local temporal continuity" of neural activity in one particular region. The concept of "local temporal continuity" signifies the linkage and integration of different discrete time points into one neural activity in a particular region. How does such local temporal continuity predispose the experience of time in consciousness? For that, I turn to phenomenological philosopher Edmund Husserl and his description of what he calls "inner time consciousness" (Husserl and Brough, 1990). One hallmark of humans' "inner time consciousness" is that we experience events and objects in succession and duration in our consciousness; according to Husserl, this amounts to what he calls the "width of [the] present." The concept of the width of present describes the extension of the present beyond the single discrete time point, such as, for instance, when we perceive different tones as a melody. I now hypothesize the degree of the width of present to be directly dependent upon and thus predisposed by the degree of the temporal differences between two (or more) discrete time points as they are encoded into neural activity. I therefore conclude that the SCPs and their encoding of neural activity in terms of temporal differences must be regarded a neural predisposition of consciousness (NPC) as distinguished from a neural correlate of consciousness (NCC).
威廉·詹姆斯假定了一种“意识流”,这种意识流预设了时间上的连续性。然而,构建这种时间连续性背后的神经元机制仍不清楚。在我的论文中,我提出了一种基于神经现象学的假设,该假设基于慢皮层电位以及它们在“当下宽度”这一现象学术语中对当下时刻的扩展。更具体地说,我关注大脑神经活动需要被编码的方式,以便使“意识流”成为可能。这再次将我们引向大脑神经活动的低频波动,更具体地说是慢皮层电位(SCPs)。由于SCPs作为低频波动具有较长的相位持续时间,它们可以在一个汇聚区域整合来自不同区域的不同刺激及其相关的神经活动。正如贺和雷奇勒最近所假定的,这种整合可能是意识产生的核心。然而,他们没有解决确切的神经元机制问题,比如编码策略,正是这种策略使得原本纯粹的神经元SCP与意识及其现象学特征产生关联成为可能。我假设SCPs通过编码基于统计的时间差异,而不是单个离散时间点本身,从而能够在物理时间中连接和关联不同的离散点。这预设了基于差异的编码而非基于刺激的编码。对这种基于统计的时间差异的编码使得“超越”刺激的仅仅物理特征成为可能;也就是说,超越它们的单个离散时间点及其传导延迟(与它们在大脑中的神经处理相关)。反过来,这使得在一个特定区域中神经活动的“局部时间连续性”的构成成为可能。“局部时间连续性”的概念表示将不同的离散时间点连接和整合到一个特定区域的神经活动中。这种局部时间连续性如何预先决定意识中的时间体验呢?为此,我转向现象学哲学家埃德蒙德·胡塞尔以及他对他所称的“内时间意识”的描述(胡塞尔和布劳,1990)。人类“内时间意识”的一个标志是,我们在意识中连续且有持续时间地体验事件和对象;根据胡塞尔的说法,这相当于他所称的“当下的宽度”。当下宽度的概念描述了当下超越单个离散时间点的扩展,例如,当我们将不同的音调感知为一段旋律时。我现在假设当下宽度的程度直接依赖于并因此由两个(或更多)离散时间点在被编码为神经活动时的时间差异程度所预先决定。因此,我得出结论,SCPs及其基于时间差异的神经活动编码必须被视为意识的神经预设(NPC),以区别于意识的神经关联物(NCC)。