Bunn Frances, Goodman Claire, Pinkney Emma, Drennan Vari M
Centre for Research in Primary and Community Care, University of Hertfordshire, Hatfield, Hertfordshire, UK.
Centre for Health and Social Care Research, Kingston University and St Georges University, London, UK.
Health Soc Care Community. 2016 Jan;24(1):48-67. doi: 10.1111/hsc.12189. Epub 2015 Feb 16.
Specialist nurses are one way of providing support for family carers of people with dementia, but relatively little is known about what these roles achieve, or if they are more effective than roles that do not require a clinical qualification. The aim of this review was to synthesise the literature on the scope and effectiveness of specialist nurses, known as Admiral Nurses, and set this evidence in the context of other community-based initiatives to support family carers of people with dementia. We undertook a systematic review of the literature relating to the scope and effectiveness of Admiral Nurses and a review of reviews of interventions to support the family carers of people with dementia. To identify studies, we searched electronic databases, undertook lateral searches and contacted experts. Searches were undertaken in November 2012. Results are reported narratively with key themes relating to Admiral Nurses identified using thematic synthesis. We included 33 items relating to Admiral Nurses (10 classified as research) and 11 reviews evaluating community-based support for carers of people with dementia. There has been little work to evaluate specific interventions provided by Admiral Nurses, but three overarching thematic categories were identified: (i) relational support, (ii) co-ordinating and personalising support and (iii) challenges and threats to the provision of services by Admiral Nurses. There was an absence of clearly articulated goals and service delivery was subject to needs of the host organisation and the local area. The reviews of community-based support for carers of people with dementia included 155 studies but, in general, evidence that interventions reduced caregiver depression or burden was weak, although psychosocial and educational interventions may reduce depression in carers. Community support for carers of people with dementia, such as that provided by Admiral Nurses, is valued by family carers, but the impact of such initiatives is not clearly established.
专科护士是为痴呆症患者的家庭护理人员提供支持的一种方式,但对于这些角色能取得什么成效,或者它们是否比不需要临床资质的角色更有效,人们了解得相对较少。本综述的目的是综合关于专科护士(即“海军上将护士”)的职责范围和有效性的文献,并将这些证据置于其他基于社区的支持痴呆症患者家庭护理人员的举措的背景下。我们对与“海军上将护士”的职责范围和有效性相关的文献进行了系统综述,并对支持痴呆症患者家庭护理人员的干预措施的综述进行了回顾。为了确定研究,我们搜索了电子数据库、进行了横向搜索并联系了专家。搜索于2012年11月进行。结果采用主题综合法以与“海军上将护士”相关的关键主题进行叙述性报告。我们纳入了33篇与“海军上将护士”相关的文献(10篇归类为研究)以及11篇评估为痴呆症患者护理人员提供的社区支持的综述。几乎没有开展评估“海军上将护士”提供的具体干预措施的工作,但确定了三个总体主题类别:(i)关系支持,(ii)协调和个性化支持,以及(iii)“海军上将护士”提供服务面临的挑战和威胁。缺乏明确阐述的目标,服务提供取决于主办组织和当地地区的需求。对为痴呆症患者护理人员提供的社区支持的综述包括155项研究,但总体而言,虽然心理社会和教育干预可能会减轻护理人员的抑郁情绪,但干预措施减轻护理人员抑郁或负担的证据并不充分。家庭护理人员重视为痴呆症患者护理人员提供的社区支持,比如“海军上将护士”提供的支持,但此类举措的影响尚未明确确立。