Rogers David J
Department of Zoology, University of Oxford, South Parks Road, Oxford OX1 3PS, UK
Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci. 2015 Apr 5;370(1665). doi: 10.1098/rstb.2013.0562.
This article explores four key questions about statistical models developed to describe the recent past and future of vector-borne diseases, with special emphasis on dengue: (1) How many variables should be used to make predictions about the future of vector-borne diseases? (2) Is the spatial resolution of a climate dataset an important determinant of model accuracy? (3) Does inclusion of the future distributions of vectors affect predictions of the futures of the diseases they transmit? (4) Which are the key predictor variables involved in determining the distributions of vector-borne diseases in the present and future? Examples are given of dengue models using one, five or 10 meteorological variables and at spatial resolutions of from one-sixth to two degrees. Model accuracy is improved with a greater number of descriptor variables, but is surprisingly unaffected by the spatial resolution of the data. Dengue models with a reduced set of climate variables derived from the HadCM3 global circulation model predictions for the 1980s are improved when risk maps for dengue's two main vectors (Aedes aegypti and Aedes albopictus) are also included as predictor variables; disease and vector models are projected into the future using the global circulation model predictions for the 2020s, 2040s and 2080s. The Garthwaite-Koch corr-max transformation is presented as a novel way of showing the relative contribution of each of the input predictor variables to the map predictions.
本文探讨了有关为描述媒介传播疾病的近期情况和未来发展而开发的统计模型的四个关键问题,特别侧重于登革热:(1)预测媒介传播疾病的未来发展需要使用多少变量?(2)气候数据集的空间分辨率是模型准确性的重要决定因素吗?(3)纳入媒介的未来分布是否会影响对其传播疾病未来情况的预测?(4)在确定当前和未来媒介传播疾病分布时涉及的关键预测变量有哪些?文中给出了使用1个、5个或10个气象变量且空间分辨率从六分之一度到两度的登革热模型示例。描述变量数量越多,模型准确性越高,但令人惊讶的是,数据的空间分辨率对其没有影响。当将登革热两种主要媒介(埃及伊蚊和白纹伊蚊)的风险地图也作为预测变量纳入时,源自HadCM3全球环流模型对20世纪80年代预测的一组简化气候变量的登革热模型得到了改进;利用全球环流模型对21世纪20年代、40年代和80年代的预测将疾病和媒介模型推算至未来。文中介绍了加思韦特 - 科赫相关最大值变换,作为一种展示每个输入预测变量对地图预测相对贡献的新方法。