Puntis Stephen, Rugkåsa Jorun, Forrest Alexandra, Mitchell Amy, Burns Tom
Mr. Puntis, Ms. Forrest, Ms. Mitchell, and Dr. Burns are with the Department of Psychiatry, University of Oxford, Oxford, United Kingdom (e-mail:
Psychiatr Serv. 2015 Apr 1;66(4):354-63. doi: 10.1176/appi.ps.201400178. Epub 2014 Dec 15.
Research investigating the association between continuity of care (CoC) and patient outcomes in mental health care is limited. A previous review (1970-2002) concluded that evidence for an association between CoC and outcomes was inconsistent and limited. This systematic review, conducted a decade later, provides an update.
Searches (1950-2014) were conducted on MEDLINE and PsycINFO. Included studies used a clearly identified measure of CoC and examined its relation to an outcome among adults (ages 18-65). Only English-language publications were included.
A total of 984 studies were identified that measured CoC. Eighteen met inclusion criteria, and 13 found an association between CoC and an outcome. As found in the previous review, studies reported conflicting results for the most frequently examined outcomes (hospitalization, symptom severity, social functioning, and service satisfaction). Little consistency was found between studies in choice of CoC measures and outcomes. Studies varied markedly in quality. Two of the three studies rated as good quality reported significant associations between CoC and social functioning. Compared with older studies, studies published since the previous systematic review (2002-2014) found a larger proportion of significant associations.
Little consistency was found in the way CoC was measured, which made it difficult to compare studies. Therefore, clear evidence about the association between CoC and outcomes remains limited. Results in regard to social functioning are encouraging. However, in order for conclusions to be made, researchers need to be more consistent with the measures they choose to allow comparison of studies.
关于精神卫生保健中连续性照护(CoC)与患者结局之间关联的研究有限。一项先前的综述(1970 - 2002年)得出结论,CoC与结局之间关联的证据并不一致且有限。十年后进行的这项系统综述提供了最新情况。
在MEDLINE和PsycINFO上进行了检索(1950 - 2014年)。纳入的研究使用了明确界定的CoC测量方法,并考察了其与18至65岁成年人结局的关系。仅纳入英文出版物。
共识别出984项测量CoC的研究。18项符合纳入标准,其中13项发现CoC与结局之间存在关联。如先前综述中所发现的,对于最常考察的结局(住院、症状严重程度、社会功能和服务满意度),各研究报告的结果相互矛盾。在CoC测量方法和结局的选择上,各研究之间几乎没有一致性。研究质量差异显著。三项质量评级为良好的研究中有两项报告了CoC与社会功能之间存在显著关联。与早期研究相比,自先前系统综述(2002 - 2014年)以来发表的研究发现显著关联的比例更大。
在CoC的测量方式上几乎没有一致性,这使得研究之间难以进行比较。因此,关于CoC与结局之间关联的明确证据仍然有限。关于社会功能的结果令人鼓舞。然而,为了得出结论,研究人员在选择测量方法时需要更加一致,以便能够对研究进行比较。