Goodwin Nicholas J, O'Farrell Sarah Ellen, Jagoe Kirstie, Rouse Jonathan, Roma Elisa, Biran Adam, Finkelstein Eric A
a Tulodo , Sydney , New South Wales , Australia.
J Health Commun. 2015;20 Suppl 1:43-54. doi: 10.1080/10810730.2014.1002958.
Despite decades of effort, around 2.8 billion people still rely on solid fuels to meet domestic energy needs. There is robust evidence this causes premature death and chronic disease, as well as wider economic, social, and environmental problems. Behavior change interventions are effective to reduce exposure to harm such as household air pollution, including those using health communications approaches. This article reports the findings of a project that reviewed the effectiveness of behavior change approaches in cleaner cooking interventions in resource-poor settings. The authors synthesized evidence of the use of behavior change techniques, along the cleaner cooking value chain, to bring positive health, economic, and environmental impacts. Forty-eight articles met the inclusion criteria, which documented 55 interventions carried out in 20 countries. The groupings of behavior change techniques most frequently used were shaping knowledge (n = 47), rewards and threats (n = 35), social support (n = 35), and comparisons (n = 16). A scorecard of behavior change effectiveness was developed to analyze a selection of case study interventions. Behavior change techniques have been used effectively as part of multilevel programs. Cooking demonstrations, the right product, and understanding of the barriers and benefits along the value chain have all played a role. Often absent are theories and models of behavior change adapted to the target audience and local context. Robust research methods are needed to track and evaluate behavior change and impact, not just technology disseminated. Behavior change approaches could then play a more prominent role as the "special sauce" in cleaner cooking interventions in resource poor settings.
尽管经过数十年的努力,仍有大约28亿人依靠固体燃料来满足家庭能源需求。有确凿证据表明,这会导致过早死亡和慢性病,以及更广泛的经济、社会和环境问题。行为改变干预措施对于减少诸如家庭空气污染等危害的暴露是有效的,包括那些采用健康传播方法的措施。本文报告了一个项目的研究结果,该项目回顾了资源匮乏地区清洁烹饪干预中行为改变方法的有效性。作者综合了在清洁烹饪价值链中使用行为改变技术以带来积极的健康、经济和环境影响的证据。48篇文章符合纳入标准,记录了在20个国家开展的55项干预措施。最常使用的行为改变技术分组是塑造知识(n = 47)、奖励和威胁(n = 35)、社会支持(n = 35)以及比较(n = 16)。开发了行为改变有效性记分卡来分析一系列案例研究干预措施。行为改变技术已作为多层次项目的一部分得到有效应用。烹饪示范以及合适的产品,还有对价值链中障碍和益处的理解都发挥了作用。但往往缺少适合目标受众和当地情况的行为改变理论和模型。需要采用强有力的研究方法来追踪和评估行为改变及其影响,而不仅仅是技术传播。这样一来,行为改变方法就能在资源匮乏地区的清洁烹饪干预中作为“特殊调味料”发挥更突出的作用。