Sheely Amanda, Kneipp Shawn M
a Department of Social Policy , London School of Economics and Political Science , London , UK.
Women Health. 2015;55(5):548-65. doi: 10.1080/03630242.2015.1022814. Epub 2015 Apr 23.
Criminal convictions are often associated with collateral consequences that limit access to the forms of employment and social services on which disadvantaged women most frequently rely--regardless of the severity of the offense. These consequences may play an important role in perpetuating health disparities by socioeconomic status and gender. We examined the extent to which research studies to date have assessed whether a criminal conviction might influence women's health by limiting access to Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) and employment, as a secondary, or "collateral" criminal conviction-related consequence. We reviewed 434 peer-reviewed journal articles retrieved from three electronic article databases and 197 research reports from three research organizations. Two reviewers independently extracted data from each eligible article or report using a standardized coding scheme. Of the sixteen eligible studies included in the review, most were descriptive. None explored whether receiving TANF modified health outcomes, despite its potential to do so. Researchers to date have not fully examined the causal pathways that could link employment, receiving TANF, and health, especially for disadvantaged women. Future research is needed to address this gap and to understand better the potential consequences of the criminal justice system involvement on the health of this vulnerable population.
刑事定罪往往伴随着附带后果,这些后果限制了弱势女性最常依赖的就业形式和社会服务——无论犯罪的严重程度如何。这些后果可能在因社会经济地位和性别导致的健康差距长期存在方面发挥重要作用。我们研究了迄今为止的研究在多大程度上评估了刑事定罪是否可能通过限制获得贫困家庭临时援助(TANF)和就业机会,作为与刑事定罪相关的次要或“附带”后果,从而影响女性的健康。我们检索了三个电子文章数据库中的434篇同行评审期刊文章以及三个研究机构的197份研究报告。两名评审员使用标准化编码方案从每篇符合条件的文章或报告中独立提取数据。在纳入综述的16项符合条件的研究中,大多数是描述性的。尽管TANF有可能改善健康结果,但没有一项研究探讨接受TANF是否会改变健康状况。迄今为止,研究人员尚未充分研究就业、接受TANF和健康之间可能存在的因果途径,尤其是对于弱势女性。需要未来的研究来填补这一空白,并更好地理解刑事司法系统介入对这一弱势群体健康的潜在后果。