Honda Ayako, Vio Ferruccio
Health Economics Unit, School of Public Health and Family Medicine, University of Cape Town, Cape Town, South Africa.
, Maputo, Mozambique.
Hum Resour Health. 2015 Apr 26;13:23. doi: 10.1186/s12960-015-0015-5.
Successfully motivating and retaining health workers is critical for the effective performance of health systems. In Mozambique, a shortage of health care professionals and low levels of staff motivation in rural and remote areas pose challenges to the provision of equitable health care delivery. This study provides quantitative information on the job preferences of non-physician health professionals in Mozambique, examining how different aspects of jobs are valued and how health professionals might respond to policy options that would post them to district hospitals in rural areas.
The study used a discrete choice experiment (DCE) to elicit the job preferences of non-physician health professionals. Data collection took place in four Mozambique provinces: Maputo City, Maputo Province, Sofala and Nampula. DCE questionnaires were administered to 334 non-physician health professionals with specialized or university training ('mid-level specialists' and N1 and N2 categories). In addition, questionnaires were administered to 123 N1 and N2 students to enable comparison of the results for those with work experience with those without and determine how new N1 and N2 graduates can be attracted to rural posts.
The results indicate that the provision of basic government housing has the greatest impact on the probability of choosing a job at a public health facility, followed by the provision of formal education opportunities and the availability of equipment and medicine at a health facility. The sub-group analysis suggests that job preferences vary according to stage of life and that incentive packages should vary accordingly. Recruitment strategies to encourage non-clinical professionals to work in rural/remote areas should also consider birthplace, as those born in rural/remote areas are more willing to work remotely.
The study was undertaken within an overarching project that aimed to develop incentive packages for non-physician health professionals assigned to work in remote/rural areas. Based on the DCE results, the project team, together with the Mozambique Ministry of Health, has developed a range of health workforce retention strategies focusing on the provision of housing benefits and professional development opportunities to be utilized when assigning non-physician health professionals to rural/remote areas.
成功激励并留住卫生工作者对于卫生系统的有效运作至关重要。在莫桑比克,农村和偏远地区医疗保健专业人员短缺以及工作人员积极性不高对提供公平的医疗服务构成了挑战。本研究提供了关于莫桑比克非医师卫生专业人员工作偏好的定量信息,考察了工作的不同方面如何被重视,以及卫生专业人员可能如何应对将他们派往农村地区县级医院的政策选择。
该研究采用离散选择实验(DCE)来引出非医师卫生专业人员的工作偏好。数据收集在莫桑比克的四个省份进行:马普托市、马普托省、索法拉省和楠普拉省。向334名接受过专业或大学培训的非医师卫生专业人员(“中级专科医生”以及N1和N2类别)发放了DCE问卷。此外,还向123名N1和N2学生发放了问卷,以便比较有工作经验者和无工作经验者的结果,并确定如何吸引新的N1和N2毕业生到农村岗位工作。
结果表明,提供基本的政府住房对选择在公共卫生机构工作的可能性影响最大,其次是提供正规教育机会以及卫生机构设备和药品的可获得性。亚组分析表明,工作偏好因生活阶段而异,激励方案也应相应有所不同。鼓励非临床专业人员到农村/偏远地区工作的招聘策略还应考虑出生地,因为出生在农村/偏远地区的人更愿意在偏远地区工作。
该研究是在一个总体项目中进行的,该项目旨在为被分配到偏远/农村地区工作的非医师卫生专业人员制定激励方案。基于DCE结果,项目团队与莫桑比克卫生部共同制定了一系列卫生人力保留策略,重点是提供住房福利和专业发展机会,以便在将非医师卫生专业人员分配到农村/偏远地区时加以利用。