Omar Amr S, Sivadasan Praveen C, Gul Mumi, Taha Rula, Tuli Alejandro Kohn, Singh Rajvir
Department of Cardiothoracic Surgery/Intensive Care Unit Section, Heart Hospital, Hamad Medical Corporation, PO Box 3050, Doha, Qatar.
Department of Critical Care Medicine, Beni Suef University, Beni Suef, Egypt.
BMC Anesthesiol. 2015 May 23;15:78. doi: 10.1186/s12871-015-0060-6.
Dissatisfaction with the intensive care unit may threaten medical care. Clarifying treatment preferences can be useful in these settings, where physician direction may influence decision making and therefore medical treatment. This study aimed to evaluate whether fast-track discharge from intensive care units affects the satisfaction of family members.
We used a single-center non-randomized trial, with all eligible family members involved. To evaluate family satisfaction, we used the Society of Critical Care Family Needs Assessment questionnaire (SCCMFNAQ). We hypothesized that those discharged within 24 h of intensive care unit admission and their families would have higher levels of satisfaction. Patients were scored using the therapeutic interventions scoring system (TISS) and additive EuroSCORE.
Two-hundred fifty-five family members were enrolled. The mean patient age was 53 years, and 92 % were male. The median satisfaction level among family members was 17.9 (range 14-31). Patients were divided into two groups, one receiving fast-track discharge (116 patients), and one whose members stayed longer (139 patients). The overall satisfaction was affected significantly by quality of the delivered care and dissatisfaction increased by lack of comfort in hospital settings, including the waiting room. No significant differences were seen between the two groups for overall satisfaction (p = 0.546) and individual components of the questionnaire. Higher satisfaction was linked to higher levels of education among family members (p = 0.045) and information being relayed by a senior physician p = 0.03 (two-tailed test).
Fast-track discharge from intensive care did not influence family satisfaction as hypothesized. Satisfaction relied on family members' level of education and the level of seniority of the physician relaying information.
对重症监护病房不满意可能会威胁到医疗护理。在这些环境中,明确治疗偏好可能会有所帮助,因为医生的指导可能会影响决策,进而影响医疗治疗。本研究旨在评估重症监护病房的快速出院是否会影响家庭成员的满意度。
我们采用了一项单中心非随机试验,纳入了所有符合条件的家庭成员。为了评估家庭满意度,我们使用了重症监护家庭需求评估问卷(SCCMFNAQ)。我们假设在重症监护病房入院后24小时内出院的患者及其家属会有更高的满意度。使用治疗干预评分系统(TISS)和欧洲心脏手术风险评估系统(EuroSCORE)对患者进行评分。
共纳入255名家庭成员。患者的平均年龄为53岁,92%为男性。家庭成员的满意度中位数为17.9(范围14 - 31)。患者被分为两组,一组接受快速出院(116例患者),另一组家属停留时间更长(139例患者)。总体满意度受到所提供护理质量的显著影响,而对医院环境(包括候诊室)缺乏舒适度会增加不满意程度。两组在总体满意度(p = 0.546)和问卷的各个组成部分方面没有显著差异。更高的满意度与家庭成员更高的教育水平(p = 0.045)以及由资深医生传达信息有关(p = 0.03,双尾检验)。
重症监护病房的快速出院并未如预期那样影响家庭满意度。满意度取决于家庭成员的教育水平以及传达信息的医生的资历水平。