Goodwin Nicholas S, Spinks Anneliese, Wasiak Jason
Department of Operations, Ambulance Victoria, Doncaster, Australia.
Department of Ecosystem Science, CSIRO, Griffith University, Brisbane, Australia.
Int Wound J. 2016 Aug;13(4):519-25. doi: 10.1111/iwj.12469. Epub 2015 Jul 15.
The aim of this systematic review was to determine the supporting evidence for the clinical use of hydrogel dressings as a first aid measure for burn wound management in the pre-hospital setting. Two authors searched three databases (Ovid Medline, Ovid Embase and The Cochrane Library) for relevant English language articles published through September 2014. Reference lists, conference proceedings and non-indexed academic journals were manually searched. A separate search was conducted using the Internet search engine Google to source additional studies from burns advisory agencies, first aid bodies, military institutions, manufacturer and paramedic websites. Two authors independently assessed study eligibility and relevance of non-traditional data forms for inclusion. Studies were independently assessed and included if Hydrogel-based burn dressings (HBD) were examined in first aid practices in the pre-hospital setting. A total of 129 studies were considered for inclusion, of which no pre-hospital studies were identified. The review highlights that current use of HBD in the pre-hospital setting appears to be driven by sources of information that do not reflect the paramedic environment. We recommend researchers in the pre-hospital settings undertake clinical trials in this field. More so, the review supports the need for expert consensus to identify key demographic, clinical and injury outcomes for clinicians and researchers undertaking further research into the use of dressings as a first aid measure.
本系统评价的目的是确定水凝胶敷料作为院前环境中烧伤创面管理急救措施临床应用的支持证据。两位作者检索了三个数据库(Ovid Medline、Ovid Embase和Cochrane图书馆),以查找截至2014年9月发表的相关英文文章。对手动检索参考文献列表、会议论文集和非索引学术期刊。使用互联网搜索引擎谷歌进行单独搜索,以从烧伤咨询机构、急救机构、军事机构、制造商和护理人员网站获取更多研究。两位作者独立评估研究的合格性以及纳入非传统数据形式的相关性。如果在院前环境的急救实践中对水凝胶基烧伤敷料(HBD)进行了研究,则对研究进行独立评估并纳入。总共考虑纳入129项研究,其中未发现院前研究。该评价强调,目前院前环境中HBD的使用似乎是由不符合护理人员环境的信息来源驱动的。我们建议院前环境的研究人员在该领域开展临床试验。更重要的是,该评价支持需要专家共识,以确定临床医生和研究人员在进一步研究将敷料用作急救措施时的关键人口统计学、临床和损伤结局。