Carter Marion W, Tregear Michelle L, Moskosky Susan B
Division of Reproductive Health, CDC, Atlanta, Georgia.
Manila Consulting Group, Inc., McLean, Virginia.
Am J Prev Med. 2015 Aug;49(2 Suppl 1):S107-15. doi: 10.1016/j.amepre.2015.03.030.
Community education may involve activities that seek to raise awareness and promote behavior change, using mass media, social media, and other media or interpersonal methods in community settings. This systematic review evaluated the evidence of the effects of community education on select short- and medium-term family planning outcomes.
Using an analytic approach drawn from the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force, multiple databases were searched for articles published from January 1985 through February 2011 describing studies of community education related to family planning in the U.S. Included articles were reviewed and assessed for potential bias using a standardized process in 2011. An updated, targeted review for the 2011-2014 period was conducted in early 2015.
Seventeen papers were identified. Most (nine) related to mass media interventions; three involved targeted print media, two involved text messaging or e-mail, two described outcome workers conducting community education, and one involved community theater. Study designs, strength of evidence, and levels of possible bias varied widely. Twelve of 15 studies that addressed outcomes such as increased awareness found positive associations with those outcomes, with six also reporting null findings. Seven of eight studies that addressed use of services reported positive associations, with two also reporting null findings. The targeted, additional review identified two other studies.
Evidence related to community education for family planning purposes is limited and highly variable. As goals of community education are usually limited to shorter-term outcomes, the evidence suggests that a range of approaches may be effective.
社区教育可能涉及旨在提高认识和促进行为改变的活动,在社区环境中利用大众媒体、社交媒体及其他媒体或人际方法。本系统评价评估了社区教育对选定的短期和中期计划生育成果影响的证据。
采用美国预防服务工作组的分析方法,检索了多个数据库,查找1985年1月至2011年2月发表的描述美国计划生育相关社区教育研究的文章。纳入的文章于2011年使用标准化流程进行审查和潜在偏倚评估。2015年初对2011 - 2014年期间进行了更新的针对性审查。
共识别出17篇论文。大多数(9篇)与大众媒体干预有关;3篇涉及针对性印刷媒体,2篇涉及短信或电子邮件,2篇描述了开展社区教育的外展工作者,1篇涉及社区戏剧。研究设计、证据强度和可能的偏倚程度差异很大。15项涉及提高认识等结果的研究中有12项发现与这些结果呈正相关,其中6项也报告了无显著结果。8项涉及服务使用的研究中有7项报告了正相关,其中2项也报告了无显著结果。针对性的额外审查又识别出另外2项研究。
与计划生育目的社区教育相关的证据有限且差异很大。由于社区教育的目标通常限于短期结果,证据表明一系列方法可能有效。