Pazol Karen, Zapata Lauren B, Tregear Stephen J, Mautone-Smith Nancy, Gavin Loretta E
Division of Reproductive Health, CDC, Atlanta, Georgia.
Division of Reproductive Health, CDC, Atlanta, Georgia.
Am J Prev Med. 2015 Aug;49(2 Suppl 1):S46-56. doi: 10.1016/j.amepre.2015.03.031.
Educational interventions can help increase knowledge of available contraceptive methods, enabling individuals to make informed decisions and use contraception more effectively. This systematic review evaluated contraceptive education interventions to guide national recommendations on quality family planning services.
Three databases (CINAHL, PubMed, and PsycINFO) were searched from 1985 through 2012 for peer-reviewed articles on educational interventions, with supplemental searches conducted through 2015. Primary outcomes were knowledge, participation in and comfort with decision making, and attitudes toward contraception. Secondary outcomes included contraceptive use behaviors and unintended pregnancy.
Database searches in 2011 identified 5,830 articles; 17 met inclusion criteria and were abstracted into evidence tables. Searches in 2012 and 2015 identified four additional studies. Studies used a wide range of tools (decision aids, written materials, audio/videotapes, and interactive games), with and without input from a healthcare provider or educator. Of 15 studies that examined the impact of educational interventions on knowledge, 14 found significant improvement using a range of tools, with and without input from a healthcare provider or educator. Fewer studies evaluated outcomes related to decision making, attitudes toward contraception, contraceptive use behaviors, or unintended pregnancy.
Results from this systematic review are consistent with evidence from the broader healthcare field suggesting that a range of educational interventions can increase knowledge. Future studies should assess what aspects of educational interventions are most effective, the extent to which it is necessary to include a healthcare provider or educator, and the extent to which educational interventions can impact behaviors.
教育干预有助于增加对现有避孕方法的了解,使个人能够做出明智的决定并更有效地使用避孕措施。本系统评价评估了避孕教育干预措施,以指导关于优质计划生育服务的国家建议。
检索了三个数据库(CINAHL、PubMed和PsycINFO),从1985年至2012年查找关于教育干预的同行评审文章,并在2015年进行了补充检索。主要结果包括知识、参与决策和对决策的舒适度以及对避孕的态度。次要结果包括避孕使用行为和意外怀孕。
2011年的数据库检索识别出5830篇文章;17篇符合纳入标准并被提炼到证据表中。2012年和2015年的检索又识别出四项研究。研究使用了广泛的工具(决策辅助工具、书面材料、音频/录像带和互动游戏),有或没有医疗保健提供者或教育者的参与。在15项研究教育干预对知识影响的研究中,14项发现使用一系列工具(有或没有医疗保健提供者或教育者的参与)有显著改善。评估与决策、对避孕的态度、避孕使用行为或意外怀孕相关结果的研究较少。
本系统评价的结果与更广泛医疗保健领域的证据一致,表明一系列教育干预可以增加知识。未来的研究应评估教育干预的哪些方面最有效、纳入医疗保健提供者或教育者的必要性程度以及教育干预对行为的影响程度。