Smith Samuel G, Pandit Anjali, Rush Steven R, Wolf Michael S, Simon Carol J
a Division of General Internal Medicine , Feinberg School of Medicine, Northwestern University , Chicago , Illinois , USA.
b Wolfson Institute of Preventive Medicine , Queen Mary University of London , London , United Kingdom.
J Health Commun. 2016;21(1):67-75. doi: 10.1080/10810730.2015.1033115. Epub 2015 Aug 27.
Studies investigating preferences for shared decision making (SDM) have focused on associations with sociodemographic variables, with few investigations exploring patient factors. We aimed to investigate the relationship between patient activation and preferences for SDM in 6 common medical decisions among a nationally representative cross-sectional survey of American adults. Adults older than 18 were recruited online (n = 2,700) and by telephone (n = 700). Respondents completed sociodemographic assessments and the Patient Activation Measure. They were also asked whether they perceived benefit (yes/no) in SDM in 6 common medical decisions. Nearly half of the sample (45.9%) reached the highest level of activation (Level 4). Activation was associated with age (p < .001), higher income (p = .001), higher education (p = .010), better self-rated health (p < .001), and fewer chronic conditions (p = .050). The proportion of people who agreed that SDM was beneficial varied from 53.1% (deciding the necessity of a diagnostic test) to 71.8% (decisions associated with making lifestyle changes). After we controlled for participant characteristics, higher activation was associated with greater perceived benefit in SDM across 4 of the 6 decisions. Preferences for SDM varied among 6 common medical scenarios. Low patient activation is an important barrier to SDM that could be ameliorated through the development of behavioral interventions.
关于共同决策(SDM)偏好的研究主要集中在与社会人口统计学变量的关联上,很少有研究探讨患者因素。我们旨在通过一项针对美国成年人的全国代表性横断面调查,研究患者激活度与6种常见医疗决策中共同决策偏好之间的关系。18岁以上的成年人通过网络(n = 2700)和电话(n = 700)进行招募。受访者完成了社会人口统计学评估和患者激活度测量。他们还被问及在6种常见医疗决策中是否认为共同决策有好处(是/否)。近一半的样本(45.9%)达到了最高激活水平(4级)。激活度与年龄(p <.001)、较高收入(p =.001)、较高教育水平(p =.010)、自我评估健康状况较好(p <.001)以及慢性病较少(p =.050)相关。认为共同决策有益的人群比例从53.1%(决定诊断测试的必要性)到71.8%(与做出生活方式改变相关的决策)不等。在我们控制了参与者特征后,在6项决策中的4项中,较高的激活度与对共同决策更大的感知益处相关。在6种常见医疗场景中,共同决策的偏好各不相同。患者激活度低是共同决策的一个重要障碍,可以通过开发行为干预措施来改善。