Williams Arthur R, Williams David D, Williams Phoebe D, Alemi Farrokh, Hesham Hosai, Donley Blaine, Kheirbek Raya E
Biomed Eng Online. 2015;14 Suppl 2(Suppl 2):S1. doi: 10.1186/1475-925X-14-S2-S1. Epub 2015 Aug 13.
Studies found that treatment symptoms of concern to oncology/hematology patients were greatly under-identified in medical records. On average, 11.0 symptoms were reported of concern to patients compared to 1.5 symptoms identified in their medical records. A solution to this problem is use of an electronic symptom checklist that can be easily accessed by patients prior to clinical consultations.
Describe the oncology Therapy-Related Symptom Checklists for Adults (TRSC) and Children (TRSC-C), which are validated bases for e-Health symptom documentation and management. The TRSC has 25 items/symptoms; the TRSC-C has 30 items/symptoms. These items capture up to 80% of the variance of patient symptoms. Measurement properties and applications with outpatients are presented. E-Health applications are indicated.
The TRSC was developed for adults (N = 282) then modified for children (N = 385). Statistical analyses have been done using correlational, epidemiologic, and qualitative methods. Extensive validation of measurement properties has been reported.
Research has found high levels of patient/clinician satisfaction, no increase in clinic costs, and strong correlations of TRSC/TRSC-C with medical outcomes. A recently published sequential cohort trial with adult outpatients at a Mayo Clinic community cancer center found TRSC use produced a 7.2% higher patient quality of life, 116% more symptoms identified/managed, and higher functional status.
DISCUSSION, IMPLICATIONS, AND FOLLOW-UP: An electronic system has been built to collect TRSC symptoms, reassure patients, and enhance patient-clinician communications. This report discusses system design and efforts made to provide an electronic system comfortable to patients. Methods used by clinicians to promote comfort and patient engagement were examined and incorporated into system design. These methods included (a) conversational data collection as opposed to survey style or standardized questionnaires, (b) short response phrases indicating understanding of the reported symptom, (c) use of open-ended questions to reduce long lists of symptoms, (d) directed questions that ask for confirmation of expected symptoms, (e) review of symptoms at designated stages, and (d) alerting patients when the computer has informed clinicians about patient-reported symptoms.
An e-Health symptom checklist (TRSC/TRSC-C) can facilitate identification, monitoring, and management of symptoms; enhance patient-clinician communications; and contribute to improved patient outcomes.
研究发现,肿瘤学/血液学患者关注的治疗症状在病历中被严重低估。平均而言,患者报告了11.0种关注的症状,而病历中识别出的症状为1.5种。解决这一问题的一个办法是使用电子症状清单,患者在临床会诊前可轻松访问。
描述成人肿瘤治疗相关症状清单(TRSC)和儿童肿瘤治疗相关症状清单(TRSC-C),它们是电子健康症状记录和管理的有效依据。TRSC有25项/症状;TRSC-C有30项/症状。这些项目涵盖了患者症状差异的80%。介绍了其测量属性及在门诊患者中的应用。指明了电子健康应用。
TRSC是为成人开发的(N = 282),然后针对儿童进行了修改(N = 385)。使用相关、流行病学和定性方法进行了统计分析。已报告了对测量属性的广泛验证。
研究发现患者/临床医生满意度较高,诊所成本没有增加,并且TRSC/TRSC-C与医疗结果有很强的相关性。梅奥诊所社区癌症中心最近对成年门诊患者进行的一项序贯队列试验发现,使用TRSC可使患者生活质量提高7.2%,识别/管理的症状增加116%,功能状态更好。
讨论、启示及后续:已建立一个电子系统来收集TRSC症状,安抚患者,并加强患者与临床医生的沟通。本报告讨论了系统设计以及为提供一个让患者舒适的电子系统所做的努力。研究了临床医生用于促进舒适度和患者参与度的方法,并将其纳入系统设计。这些方法包括:(a)对话式数据收集,而非调查式或标准化问卷;(b)用简短回应短语表示对所报告症状的理解;(c)使用开放式问题以减少症状清单过长;(d)直接提问以确认预期症状;(e)在指定阶段审查症状;(f)当计算机已将患者报告的症状告知临床医生时提醒患者。
电子健康症状清单(TRSC/TRSC-C)可促进症状的识别、监测和管理;加强患者与临床医生的沟通;并有助于改善患者预后。