Ahmed Samrah, Brennan Laura, Eppig Joel, Price Catherine C, Lamar Melissa, Delano-Wood Lisa, Bangen Katherine J, Edmonds Emily C, Clark Lindsey, Nation Daniel A, Jak Amy, Au Rhoda, Swenson Rodney, Bondi Mark W, Libon David J
a Nuffield Department of Clinical Neurosciences , University of Oxford, John Radcliffe Hospital , Oxford , United Kingdom.
b Department of Neurology , Drexel University College of Medicine , Philadelphia , Pennsylvania.
Appl Neuropsychol Adult. 2016;23(1):43-52. doi: 10.1080/23279095.2014.1003067. Epub 2015 Sep 23.
Clock Drawing Test performance was examined alongside other neuropsychological tests in mild cognitive impairment (MCI). We tested the hypothesis that clock-drawing errors are related to executive impairment. The current research examined 86 patients with MCI for whom, in prior research, cluster analysis was used to sort patients into dysexecutive (dMCI, n = 22), amnestic (aMCI, n = 13), and multidomain (mMCI, n = 51) subtypes. First, principal components analysis (PCA) and linear regression examined relations between clock-drawing errors and neuropsychological test performance independent of MCI subtype. Second, between-group differences were assessed with analysis of variance (ANOVA) where MCI subgroups were compared to normal controls (NC). PCA yielded a 3-group solution. Contrary to expectations, clock-drawing errors loaded with lower performance on naming/lexical retrieval, rather than with executive tests. Regression analyses found increasing clock-drawing errors to command were associated with worse performance only on naming/lexical retrieval tests. ANOVAs revealed no differences in clock-drawing errors between dMCI versus mMCI or aMCI versus NCs. Both the dMCI and mMCI groups generated more clock-drawing errors than the aMCI and NC groups in the command condition. In MCI, language-related skills contribute to clock-drawing impairment.
在轻度认知障碍(MCI)患者中,我们将画钟试验表现与其他神经心理学测试一起进行了检查。我们检验了画钟错误与执行功能障碍相关的假设。当前研究对86例MCI患者进行了检查,在之前的研究中,使用聚类分析将患者分为执行功能障碍型(dMCI,n = 22)、遗忘型(aMCI,n = 13)和多领域型(mMCI,n = 51)亚型。首先,主成分分析(PCA)和线性回归研究了画钟错误与神经心理学测试表现之间的关系,且不考虑MCI亚型。其次,采用方差分析(ANOVA)评估组间差异,将MCI亚组与正常对照组(NC)进行比较。PCA得出了一个三组解决方案。与预期相反,画钟错误与命名/词汇检索方面较低的表现相关,而不是与执行测试相关。回归分析发现,指令性画钟错误增加仅与命名/词汇检索测试中的较差表现相关。方差分析显示,dMCI与mMCI之间或aMCI与NC之间在画钟错误方面没有差异。在指令条件下,dMCI组和mMCI组产生的画钟错误均多于aMCI组和NC组。在MCI中,与语言相关的技能导致画钟功能受损。