Thorisson A, Smedh K, Torkzad M R, Påhlman L, Chabok A
Int J Colorectal Dis. 2016 Feb;31(2):451-7. doi: 10.1007/s00384-015-2423-3. Epub 2015 Oct 21.
The first randomized clinical trial of antibiotics in uncomplicated diverticulitis (the AVOD study) showed no benefit of antibiotics. The aim of this study was to re-evaluate the computed tomography (CT) scans of the patients in the AVOD study to find out whether there were CT findings that were missed and to study whether CT signs in uncomplicated diverticulitis could predict complications or recurrence.
The CT scan images from patients included in the AVOD study were re-evaluated and graded by two independent reviewers for different signs of diverticulitis, including complications, such as extraluminal gas or the presence of an abscess.
Of the 623 patients included in the study, 602 CT scans were obtained and re-evaluated. Forty-four (7 %) patients were found to have complications on the admitting CT scan that had been overlooked. Twenty-seven had extraluminal gas and 17 had an abscess. Four of these patients deteriorated and required surgery, but the remaining patients improved without complications. Of the 18 patients in the no-antibiotic group, in whom signs of complications on CT were overlooked, 15 recovered without antibiotics. No CT findings in patients with uncomplicated diverticulitis could predict complications or recurrence.
No CT findings that could predict complications or recurrence were found. A weakness in the initial assessment of the CT scans to detect extraluminal gas and abscess was found but, despite this, the majority of patients recovered without antibiotics. This further supports the non-antibiotic strategy in uncomplicated diverticulitis.
抗生素用于单纯性憩室炎的首个随机临床试验(AVOD研究)显示抗生素并无益处。本研究的目的是重新评估AVOD研究中患者的计算机断层扫描(CT)图像,以找出是否存在被遗漏的CT表现,并研究单纯性憩室炎的CT征象能否预测并发症或复发情况。
由两名独立的评估人员对AVOD研究中患者的CT扫描图像进行重新评估,并根据憩室炎的不同表现进行分级,包括并发症,如腔外气体或脓肿的存在。
在纳入研究的623例患者中,获取并重新评估了602份CT扫描图像。发现在入院时的CT扫描中有44例(7%)患者存在被忽视的并发症。27例有腔外气体存在,17例有脓肿。其中4例患者病情恶化,需要进行手术,但其余患者病情好转,未出现并发症。在未使用抗生素组的18例患者中,其CT上的并发症征象被忽视,其中15例未使用抗生素即康复。单纯性憩室炎患者的CT表现无法预测并发症或复发情况。
未发现能够预测并发症或复发的CT表现。发现了在最初评估CT扫描以检测腔外气体和脓肿方面存在不足,尽管如此,大多数患者未使用抗生素即康复。这进一步支持了单纯性憩室炎的非抗生素治疗策略。