Postma M, Backhans A, Collineau L, Loesken S, Sjölund M, Belloc C, Emanuelson U, Grosse Beilage E, Stärk K D C, Dewulf J
1Veterinary Epidemiology Unit,Department of Reproduction, Obstetrics and Herd Health, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine,Ghent University,Salisburylaan 133,9820 Merelbeke,Belgium.
2Department of Animal Health and Antimicrobial Strategies,National Veterinary Institute,SVA,SE-751 89 Uppsala,Sweden.
Animal. 2016 Mar;10(3):478-89. doi: 10.1017/S1751731115002487. Epub 2015 Nov 16.
Disease prevention through biosecurity measures is believed to be an important factor for improvement of the overall health status in animal production. This study aimed at assessing the levels of implementation of biosecurity measures in pig production in four European Union (EU) countries and to describe possible associations between the biosecurity level and farm and production characteristics. A cross-sectional study was conducted in 232 farrow-to-finish pig herds in Belgium, France, Germany and Sweden between December 2012 and December 2013. The biosecurity status in each of these herds was described and quantified by using the risk-based scoring tool Biocheck.UGentTM (www.biocheck.ugent.be). Production and management characteristics, obtained from the herd management system and by interviewing the farmer, were analysed for their association with the biosecurity level. A causal path was designed to study statistical associations. The results showed that there was substantial room for improvement in the biosecurity status on many pig farms. Significant differences (P<0.01) both in internal and external biosecurity levels were observed between countries. The external biosecurity status, combining all measures taken to prevent disease introduction into the herd, was highest in Germany and lowest in France. The internal biosecurity status, combining all measures taken to prevent within herd disease transmission, was highest in Sweden and lowest, with a large variation, in Belgium. External biosecurity scores were in general higher compared to internal biosecurity scores. The number of pathogens vaccinated against was significantly associated with internal biosecurity status, suggesting an overall more preventive approach towards the risk of disease transmission. A higher external biosecurity was associated with more weaned piglets per sow per year. Furthermore also the weaning age and the mortality till weaning were highly associated with the number of weaned piglets per sow per year. The negative association observed between the biosecurity level and the estimated frequency of treatment against certain clinical signs of disease as a proxy for disease incidence is consistent with the hypothesis that a higher biosecurity level results in healthier animals. These findings promote an improved biosecurity status at pig farms and are of relevance in the discussion on alternative ways to keep animals healthy with a reduced necessity of antimicrobials; Prevention is better than cure!
通过生物安全措施预防疾病被认为是改善动物生产总体健康状况的一个重要因素。本研究旨在评估欧盟四个国家生猪生产中生物安全措施的实施水平,并描述生物安全水平与农场及生产特征之间可能存在的关联。2012年12月至2013年12月期间,对比利时、法国、德国和瑞典的232个从产仔到育肥的猪群进行了一项横断面研究。使用基于风险的评分工具Biocheck.UGentTM(www.biocheck.ugent.be)对每个猪群的生物安全状况进行描述和量化。从猪群管理系统以及通过与养殖户访谈获取生产和管理特征,并分析它们与生物安全水平的关联。设计了一条因果路径来研究统计关联。结果表明,许多猪场的生物安全状况仍有很大的改善空间。各国在内部和外部生物安全水平上均观察到显著差异(P<0.01)。综合所有为防止疾病传入猪群而采取的措施的外部生物安全状况,德国最高,法国最低。综合所有为防止猪群内疾病传播而采取的措施的内部生物安全状况,瑞典最高,比利时最低且差异较大。外部生物安全评分总体上高于内部生物安全评分。接种疫苗预防的病原体数量与内部生物安全状况显著相关,这表明对疾病传播风险总体上采取了更具预防性的方法。较高的外部生物安全水平与每年每头母猪断奶仔猪数量较多相关。此外,断奶年龄和断奶前死亡率也与每年每头母猪断奶仔猪数量高度相关。生物安全水平与针对某些疾病临床症状的估计治疗频率(作为疾病发病率的替代指标)之间观察到的负相关与以下假设一致,即较高的生物安全水平会使动物更健康。这些发现促进了猪场生物安全状况的改善,并且在关于以减少抗菌药物使用需求的替代方法来保持动物健康的讨论中具有相关性;预防胜于治疗!