Winkelman M
Department of Anthropology, Arizona State University, Tempe 85287-2402.
J Psychoactive Drugs. 1989 Jan-Mar;21(1):17-24. doi: 10.1080/02791072.1989.10472139.
The issue of cross-cultural similarities and differences in trance practitioners engaged in healing is examined, based on a formal quantitative cross-cultural study and analysis. The findings suggest distinct types of healers: shamans, shaman/healers, healers, and mediums. The data illustrate not only some universals of healers, but more importantly it reveals systematic differences between the shamans of hunting and gathering societies, the shaman/healers of agricultural societies, and the possessed mediums of politically stratified societies. These different types of trance healers are characterized and compared in order to illustrate the importance of terminological clarity, as well as to examine the characteristics and functions of shamanistic healers with respect to the social and cultural context of their activities.
基于一项正式的定量跨文化研究与分析,对从事治疗的出神从业者的跨文化异同问题进行了考察。研究结果表明存在不同类型的治疗师:萨满、萨满/治疗师、治疗师和灵媒。数据不仅说明了治疗师的一些共性,更重要的是揭示了狩猎采集社会的萨满、农业社会的萨满/治疗师以及政治分层社会中被附身的灵媒之间的系统性差异。对这些不同类型的出神治疗师进行了特征描述和比较,以阐明术语清晰的重要性,并考察萨满治疗师在其活动的社会和文化背景下的特征与功能。