Liu Xu, Tang Bihan, Yang Hongyang, Liu Yuan, Xue Chen, Zhang Lulu
Department of Military Health Management, College of Military Health Management, Second Military Medical University, Shanghai 200433, China.
Department of Medical Affairs, Second Artillery General Hospital of Chinese People's Liberation Army, Beijing 100088, China.
Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2015 Dec 4;12(12):15390-9. doi: 10.3390/ijerph121214991.
Performance assessments of earthquake medical rapid response teams (EMRRTs), particularly the first responders deployed to the hardest hit areas following major earthquakes, should consider efficient and effective use of resources. This study assesses the daily technical efficiency of EMRRTs in the emergency period immediately following the 2010 Yushu earthquake in China.
Data on EMRRTs were obtained from official daily reports of the general headquarters for Yushu earthquake relief, the emergency office of the National Ministry of Health, and the Health Department of Qinghai Province, for a sample of data on 15 EMRRTs over 62 days. Data envelopment analysis was used to examine the technical efficiency in a constant returns to scale model, a variable returns to scale model, and the scale efficiency of EMRRTs. Tobit regression was applied to analyze the effects of corresponding influencing factors.
The average technical efficiency scores under constant returns to scale, variable returns to scale, and the scale efficiency scores of the 62 units of analysis were 77.95%, 89.00%, and 87.47%, respectively. The staff-to-bed ratio was significantly related to global technical efficiency. The date of rescue was significantly related to pure technical efficiency. The type of institution to which an EMRRT belonged and the staff-to-bed ratio were significantly related to scale efficiency.
This study provides evidence that supports improvements to EMRRT efficiency and serves as a reference for earthquake emergency medical rapid assistance leaders and teams.
对地震医疗快速反应团队(EMRRTs)进行绩效评估,尤其是对在大地震后被部署到受灾最严重地区的首批救援人员进行评估时,应考虑资源的高效利用。本研究评估了2010年中国玉树地震后紧急时期EMRRTs的每日技术效率。
EMRRTs的数据来自玉树地震救灾总指挥部、国家卫生部应急办公室和青海省卫生厅的官方每日报告,样本为15个EMRRTs在62天内的数据。数据包络分析用于检验在规模报酬不变模型、规模报酬可变模型下EMRRTs的技术效率以及规模效率。采用Tobit回归分析相应影响因素的作用。
在规模报酬不变、规模报酬可变情况下,62个分析单元的平均技术效率得分分别为77.95%、89.00%,规模效率得分为87.47%。医护人员与床位比与整体技术效率显著相关。救援日期与纯技术效率显著相关。EMRRT所属机构类型和医护人员与床位比与规模效率显著相关。
本研究为提高EMRRT效率提供了支持证据,可为地震应急医疗快速援助的领导者和团队提供参考。